The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[witchblades]

is this fair? [x]
PLEASE HELP ASAP AND THANK YOU IN ADVANCE.

[pigeon -]

is this fair? [x]
PLEASE HELP ASAP AND THANK YOU IN ADVANCE.

unfair to them, the dragon store is only worth a late '10 rare c:

[,rain]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68382764&userid=774929&signature=mzUXGxQeWHX5bXLbMUWxkg

Is this fair? I don't love the trade but I do like the valentine dog. I know the malk dragon goes for a lot but I don't like dragons.

Rarity wise that's incredible overpay on their side
Demand wise I couldn't tell you, I'm not too read up on demand for the Cheshire, but their side is mostly malks which I know also have a good demand value

Thank you! Any second opinions regarding demand?

[huskypawz]

is this fair? [x]
PLEASE HELP ASAP AND THANK YOU IN ADVANCE.

I'd say over trade on the top's side, because store pets, once they leave the store, can go for an 09 rare, which covers the nick dog, but the common isn't enough for the rare fox. It also depends on how you value store pets and Nick pets. Some people value them as more than their worth, others value them as less. Personally, I agree with it being over the the top, but it's up to you and your trade partner.

[HorseDad]

is this fair? [x]
PLEASE HELP ASAP AND THANK YOU IN ADVANCE.

I'd say over trade on the top's side, because store pets, once they leave the store, can go for an 09 rare, which covers the nick dog, but the common isn't enough for the rare fox. It also depends on how you value store pets and Nick pets. Some people value them as more than their worth, others value them as less. Personally, I agree with it being over the the top, but it's up to you and your trade partner.

The nick dog alone is an overpay,

[huskypawz]

is this fair? [x]
PLEASE HELP ASAP AND THANK YOU IN ADVANCE.

I'd say over trade on the top's side, because store pets, once they leave the store, can go for an 09 rare, which covers the nick dog, but the common isn't enough for the rare fox. It also depends on how you value store pets and Nick pets. Some people value them as more than their worth, others value them as less. Personally, I agree with it being over the the top, but it's up to you and your trade partner.

The nick dog alone is an overpay,

That's your opinion <3 a lot of people don't like Nick dogs, so the value can drop. Depends on people's views.

[huskypawz]

Is this fair?

[storm coming.]

Is this fair?



fair since the gap between the
two list pets is a 2009 rare. ^^

[dear.chaton]

How's this? I'm not sure
and if its not fair what should I add?

[sirius]

is this trade fair? Should i accept?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... o2otD8PHuw

Thanks!! (: