The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Alerian]

Is this fair. I think it's a over-trade to me.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eBVQLf0zQw

Unfair towards you.

Lets just say, those other pets aren't even there. The 2013 storepet dog is worth a 2009 VR. The other pets dont even really add anything to the table. So, very unfair.

Actually, i disagree.

I'd say it's slightly unfair to them. The 2013 store pet is worth a early '09 rare/very rare. It can be worth either a rare or very rare depending on the user. It would only take a few uncommons + the rare to equal the store pet

[AstralFire]

Is this fair. I think it's a over-trade to me.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eBVQLf0zQw

Unfair towards you.

Lets just say, those other pets aren't even there. The 2013 storepet dog is worth a 2009 VR. The other pets dont even really add anything to the table. So, very unfair.

Thank you for the advice.

[hyukoh]

how is this demand wise??
thank you for any help. what can the UR bengal get?

I would go for this, because the bengal goes for a sorbet and the patchwork for around a UR rat

thank you; second opinion please?? is the bengal easy to trade off??
(meaning does it go for fair trades or overpay/underpay?)

also let's say the zodiacs are out of the picture. i dont really value them by much so they dont really make
this trade any better

[jade,]

Another opinion on this? How much would it take to fill the gap? Please help!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eU762W_Aug

[vignette]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68487112&userid=684365&signature=2bC3q1SNZc1vEKwkfx6ecw

Is this fair? Their side has 4 2009 staff litter

I've been trying for about 3 hours, anyone??

[AstralFire]

Is this fair. I think it's a over-trade to me.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eBVQLf0zQw

Unfair towards you.

Lets just say, those other pets aren't even there. The 2013 storepet dog is worth a 2009 VR. The other pets dont even really add anything to the table. So, very unfair.

Actually, i disagree.

I'd say it's slightly unfair to them. The 2013 store pet is worth a early '09 rare/very rare. It can be worth either a rare or very rare depending on the user. It would only take a few uncommons + the rare to equal the store pet

So it's a over-trade on their side?

[Alerian]

Another opinion on this? How much would it take to fill the gap? Please help!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eU762W_Aug

I'd say roughly 1 sorbet.

The Cucumber is worth 2 Nons + yellow toxic tier while the Pineapple is worth 2 sorbets + UR apple.
The UR BW is worth 3 nons + Purple toxic tier. The Cucumber side is around 1 sorbet short.

So it's a over-trade on their side?

Yes. The 09' rare they offered is late so it's not quite worth the 2013.

[Topsy Turvey]

Is this fair?

[Yeens]

Fair?

[Sammythecat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wa1QueV8EQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8UuQhziGpw

Are these fair rarity and demand wise? Thanks!