The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Sphinxtea]

Is this fair would you except it?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... i3C7aaJSUA

[Smaug The Dragon]

this? What needs to be added and/ or taken away to what side? Fast replies would be necessary.

[noctonia]

Hi. Would this trade be fair? Thank you!

[Winter526]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jW0j9Z7WzQ

So which one is more fair to the other person and how to make it more fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... peFd1iWUrA

[LittleHalo]

is this fair? please help

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vqT5IrqEVA

30+50+40
The 2012 store pet would be c$50, corgi would be c$40 so all together would be c$120. The grown white scarf dog (which is in the same tier as the cat) is worth about c$55 so they're overpaying.

Second Opinion please?

I disagree because C$ doesn't work that way. If you go off what they said that means they offered you a T1 September List, which is absolutely not true. The Corgi goes for a 2009 rare based off of it's demand, and the Alien Dog goes for 1-2 2009 rares. C$30 is about a late 2009 rare or an early 2010 rare. In my personal opinion, they're under by a little bit. Depending how you value it, it may be fair. The cat is worth 3-4 2009 rares, I don't know how you value it (I value it at 4).[/quote]

Ahhh help xc???

[Coleslaw]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67848106&userid=348410&signature=F0V3KFXQduNHFh8-9YUKmA

Is this alright? I can't seem to find where the lion was originally on the archive, but I think it was a rerelease

May 2010
The demand of the lion has died down since release, i remember people had paid ridiculous amounts for it because it was one of the first lionesses on the site, after the Christmas 2009 lionesses had been released.
As far as fairness, strictly value they are overpaying. Demand wise is say it's still sought after, so that's fair imo. You could get a second opinion though, I haven't had touch with the lioness trades in a while

[

is this fair? please help

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vqT5IrqEVA

Ahhh help xc???

It's your personal preference. To be technical, the store pets will only get rarer. The list pets and everything else that was free on the site gets re released every year, and the rarity drops just a little. That's why the raven dog is going for Nons right now. If you wanna "invest" I'd take it, you'll always have a chance at rerelease. ✌🏼 Just my two cents, hope it helps~

[Cartier]

I was told this is very unfair.
A 2014 for 4 2016s..

Is it not 2 commons from one year = one from the previous year? Therefore 4 2016 commons = 1 2014 common?

[Lillysong]

I was told this is very unfair.
A 2014 for 4 2016s..

Is it not 2 commons from one year = one from the previous year? Therefore 4 2016 commons = 1 2014 common?

Technically, it is fair. You're right.

[ThunderCedar]

I was told this is very unfair.
A 2014 for 4 2016s..

Is it not 2 commons from one year = one from the previous year? Therefore 4 2016 commons = 1 2014 common?

This is fair.

[Banana Dancer :)]

I was told this is very unfair.
A 2014 for 4 2016s..

Is it not 2 commons from one year = one from the previous year? Therefore 4 2016 commons = 1 2014 common?

It looks fair but they might be looking at the month as well and it’s a 9 month difference