The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[watery>~<]

please help! is this fair!? Tysm in advance!

You're overpaying

Please explain why they are overpaying
Ok so, their side is only worht a 2014 + 2015 uncommon while yours is a 2011
They would have to add a 2015 uncommon, 2013 uncommon and a 2012 uncommon to make the trade fair

Agreed

[LittleHalo]

is this fair? please help

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vqT5IrqEVA

30+50+40
The 2012 store pet would be c$50, corgi would be c$40 so all together would be c$120. The grown white scarf dog (which is in the same tier as the cat) is worth about c$55 so they're overpaying.

Second Opinion please?

[watery>~<]

is this fair? please help

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vqT5IrqEVA

30+50+40
The 2012 store pet would be c$50, corgi would be c$40 so all together would be c$120. The grown white scarf dog (which is in the same tier as the cat) is worth about c$55 so they're overpaying.

Second Opinion please?

I agree and even if it's rarity wise not C$ wise, they're still overpaying (by approximately 20C$ aka a '10 or '09 rare i think)
Edit no wait, it would be fair since the cat is worth 3-4 09 rares sorry! But C$ wise im pretty sure its unfair to them

[Sphinxtea]

Is this fair would you except it?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... i3C7aaJSUA

[cocovater]

Would you accept this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E86czewxoQ
Multiple opinions please! Thank you

[RainWingThing]

is this fair? please help

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vqT5IrqEVA

30+50+40
The 2012 store pet would be c$50, corgi would be c$40 so all together would be c$120. The grown white scarf dog (which is in the same tier as the cat) is worth about c$55 so they're overpaying.

Second Opinion please?

I disagree because C$ doesn't work that way. If you go off what they said that means they offered you a T1 September List, which is absolutely not true. The Corgi goes for a 2009 rare based off of it's demand, and the Alien Dog goes for 1-2 2009 rares. C$30 is about a late 2009 rare or an early 2010 rare. In my personal opinion, they're under by a little bit. Depending how you value it, it may be fair. The cat is worth 3-4 2009 rares, I don't know how you value it (I value it at 4).

[Mew5522]

Would you accept this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E86czewxoQ
Multiple opinions please! Thank you

I think it's unfair to you since even though it's a very rare I think it should be worth around two rares expecially since your pets are all from a lot earlier times than theirs. Also I think the pets on your side might be in higher demand than theirs(I'm certain but from what i've seen I think they are). I'm not really an expert or anything but I hope that it's some what useful

[aestheticShadows]

I've always been confused on item worths, so is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BuSP0G388g

[RainWingThing]

Would you accept this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E86czewxoQ
Multiple opinions please! Thank you

I think it's unfair to you since even though it's a very rare I think it should be worth around two rares expecially since your pets are all from a lot earlier times than theirs. Also I think the pets on your side might be in higher demand than theirs(I'm certain but from what i've seen I think they are). I'm not really an expert or anything but I hope that it's some what useful :)

The butterfly wolf is a re-release from 2009. I agree with it being valued at two rares, and since horses don't necessarily have the best demand I think the three rares works fine. That's just my opinion, I think it's fair.

[Fenric]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67848106&userid=348410&signature=F0V3KFXQduNHFh8-9YUKmA

Is this alright? I can't seem to find where the lion was originally on the archive, but I think it was a rerelease