The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Finalized]

is this good?

One of the most common offers in exchange for the Raven dog is a CEG/BEG. I personally feel as if you could get more, but the BEG has lovely demand so either way it's worth taking, and worth declining. You can get higher list placed pets, but most of which don't have as good demand as the BEG.

[~hakuna matata~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67264861&userid=696582&signature=Uul2bs5pR7CxP69_ymlv8w

I am really liking this bid and may auto soon

Can I get some opinions please?

[honeycombs]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67264861&userid=696582&signature=Uul2bs5pR7CxP69_ymlv8w

I am really liking this bid and may auto soon

Can I get some opinions please?

I think for you, it's fair, but to me, it's not. They are giving you 2 rares/2 very rares and 5 chicken dollars when all he/she wants is a very rare. I'd rather say, decline, send a new trade with your pet, and the 2 very rares, but you should just pick one. It seems unfair when a person wants one thing but they offer more.

[ruel]

Help!

Was this a fair trade? Could i get more out of the dragon than all of the pets i traded away? Thanks in advanced!

also is This fair for my sunjewel?

Another trade for my sunjewel! Trade

Is it a bird? Is it a plane? Nope! Its another trade for my SunJewel ;-;
Le Trade

oh hey look is that a Trade for my malk dragon?

ANOTHER trade for my sunjewel ;-;

heres one more trade for my sunjewel
;-;

[myth;]

Help!

Was this a fair trade? Could i get more out of the dragon than all of the pets i traded away? Thanks in advanced!

also is This fair for my sunjewel?

Another trade for my sunjewel! Trade

Is it a bird? Is it a plane? Nope! Its another trade for my SunJewel ;-;
Le Trade

oh hey look is that a Trade for my malk dragon?

ANOTHER trade for my sunjewel ;-;

heres one more trade for my sunjewel
;-;

1= Given the bad demand of the cake dog, I think that was unfair to the dragon, but you can definitely get more than that for one. They have great demand.

2= The July PPS is worth 2 nons I think, so is unfair to the Sun Jewel by 3 nons, but the PPS has bad demand and trades for 1 non. The other pets have no impact on the overall trade as they have no special demand.

3= The banana and cucumber trade for 1 to 1.5 nons each, added to the true non it only comes to 3-4 nons, which is unfair to the sun jewel by 1 or 2 non. Please bare in mind that the cucumber and banana have bad demand and are hard to trade on.

4= I've no idea how to add all these pets together, but I know they do not add to even 3 nons and are unfair to the Sun Jewel.

5= Is my trade welp I love dragons okay

6= The cat is worth 2 nons and 2 sorbets, added to the other two pets it nearly reaches 4 nons, which is still 1 non off. But the cat has really good demand and can probably fetch 3 nons. I think this trade is best. ^^'

7= Doesn't even reach a non, so is extremely unfair.

I hope this is all correct, please feel free to get a second opinion.

[ruel]

Help!

Was this a fair trade? Could i get more out of the dragon than all of the pets i traded away? Thanks in advanced!

also is This fair for my sunjewel?

Another trade for my sunjewel! Trade

Is it a bird? Is it a plane? Nope! Its another trade for my SunJewel ;-;
Le Trade

oh hey look is that a Trade for my malk dragon?

ANOTHER trade for my sunjewel ;-;

heres one more trade for my sunjewel
;-;

1= Given the bad demand of the cake dog, I think that was unfair to the dragon, but you can definitely get more than that for one. They have great demand.

2= The July PPS is worth 2 nons I think, so is unfair to the Sun Jewel by 3 nons, but the PPS has bad demand and trades for 1 non. The other pets have no impact on the overall trade as they have no special demand.

3= The banana and cucumber trade for 1 to 1.5 nons each, added to the true non it only comes to 3-4 nons, which is unfair to the sun jewel by 1 or 2 non. Please bare in mind that the cucumber and banana have bad demand and are hard to trade on.

4= I've no idea how to add all these pets together, but I know they do not add to even 3 nons and are unfair to the Sun Jewel.

5= Is my trade welp I love dragons okay

6= The cat is worth 2 nons and 2 sorbets, added to the other two pets it nearly reaches 4 nons, which is still 1 non off. But the cat has really good demand and can probably fetch 3 nons. I think this trade is best. ^^'

7= Doesn't even reach a non, so is extremely unfair.

I hope this is all correct, please feel free to get a second opinion.

Thank you so much!!! you are a life saver oh my gosh xD

[Quackers <3]

Hello! I was wondering if I could get a few opinions on a couple of the bids in my auction. Just mainly curious as to which one you would take and why.

One
Two
Three
Four
Five

[Yeens]

how fair is this for chicken plushie?

patchwork trade need help with demand

[Guest]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67264861&userid=696582&signature=Uul2bs5pR7CxP69_ymlv8w

I am really liking this bid and may auto soon

Can I get some opinions please?

I think for you, it's fair, but to me, it's not. They are giving you 2 rares/2 very rares and 5 chicken dollars when all he/she wants is a very rare. I'd rather say, decline, send a new trade with your pet, and the 2 very rares, but you should just pick one. It seems unfair when a person wants one thing but they offer more.

Some people are willing to trade more for the pets that they want, as long as they know the value of their pet and what they are offering it's not unfair at all ^-^
And considering that this is an auction people naturally end up overpaying for the pet so it's not such a big deal!
The bid is really nice, they are paying almost 2 times what the dog is worth, but I personally wouldn't auto it because of the pony! It can be really hard to trade off and since your pet has really nice demand you might be able to get a similar offer with a dog instead of a pony

[torbie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QnTBXPTiQQ
Is this fair?