The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Mewfle]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67189512&userid=583182&signature=yIcnamUaSoKzaqzLqkWRAw
is this fair, demand wise? i have no idea how much the pps dragon goes for these days...
can i get a second (or third) opinion on this trade? my partner keeps insisting that the pps dragon is worth a sorbet but i also hear that it's worth less than a sorbet :[

Demand wise is up to you at this point ^^
The dragon pps did have a demand spike a while ago, and it did actually go for a sorbet then.
However, it’s been a while, so I’m leaning towards that it’s demand value has dropped quite a bit since then. While personally I wouldn’t pay higher than a balloon dog tier for one, others will have other opinions and value it at higher or lower than the balloon dog tier.

I probably wouldn’t take this trade, just because the BA’s demand has been pretty steady and can fetch a sorbet often, while the dragon pps is well..confusing I suppose.
Anyways, it’s up to you after all :’D

Hello! Is this fair?

Corgis were extended into 2014 so this is unfair to you due to the year gap.

Thanks! Can I get a second opinion, including demand?

There’s not really any real demand within the “regular” store pets (Cheshire and dragon cat pps excluded from this)
It’s just that some people choose to overpay slightly for certain pets.
So yeah, it’s unfair to you.

[Sarcastic Hawke]

Would this trade be considered fair to my Timberwolf with demand included? Any help is appreciated =^D

[soupy.]

I want one last opinion...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67208853&userid=814854&signature=JpjyA2cOwmmdLWcT7wDDJA
I took off some C$

[Kaname]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67189512&userid=583182&signature=yIcnamUaSoKzaqzLqkWRAw
is this fair, demand wise? i have no idea how much the pps dragon goes for these days...
can i get a second (or third) opinion on this trade? my partner keeps insisting that the pps dragon is worth a sorbet but i also hear that it's worth less than a sorbet :[

Demand wise is up to you at this point ^^
The dragon pps did have a demand spike a while ago, and it did actually go for a sorbet then.
However, it’s been a while, so I’m leaning towards that it’s demand value has dropped quite a bit since then. While personally I wouldn’t pay higher than a balloon dog tier for one, others will have other opinions and value it at higher or lower than the balloon dog tier.

I probably wouldn’t take this trade, just because the BA’s demand has been pretty steady and can fetch a sorbet often, while the dragon pps is well..confusing I suppose.
Anyways, it’s up to you after all :’D

thank you so much for the great, informative answer. i didn't know that it did go for a sorbet then, i haven't been going on for much lately. i guess i'll decline for the stable value of the ba, i guess.. though i do love the dragon pps xD thank you again!!

[Horsesrule5000]

What trade is worth more for the UR Peach? What one would you accept?
Trade 1:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rQ8gmXFWmg
Trade 2:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OkprIobXog

[444cupid]

I want one last opinion...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67208853&userid=814854&signature=JpjyA2cOwmmdLWcT7wDDJA
I took off some C$

Hmm, I would say its unfair to you, this is a mainlist, but, they do have lists included, but the ur b wolf is VERY hard to find, but the items and pets aren't as hard, just my opinion

[waggy]

would appreciate some help cause I don't know.thanks.

[akyr]

please help aaaaaaaaaa

[Kaname]

please help aaaaaaaaaa

unfair to them by 3 rares, i believe that pet is from 2009 so only one 2009 rare would work

[holodog]

Hi, would anyone be able to help with the fairness of this trade and what possibly needs to be added to either side? Thanks!