The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Peppermint Mist]

thanks for the feedback before! I now have it down to these two bids
bid 1
bid 2
which bid is better? thanks in advance!

[holodog]

Item, C$ and pet trade
Is this fair/what would need to be added to make it fair? Thank you in advance for any advice!

[OHHAILTHECHOOKOFLIFE]

thanks for the feedback before! I now have it down to these two bids
bid 1
bid 2
which bid is better? thanks in advance!

A patchy pink Sept list is worth 190-230 C$ so the 300C$ one is overpaying...
By the list ^^

My 100% personal opinion. This isn't correct any other way but this is what I'll do
I find it hard to buy list pets with C$ so I'll go with the Sept list. Other people will accept the c $ but this is my honest opinion. You dont have to take this into account

[myth;]

Is a UR Aussie dog fair for a GWJ and UR Foal?
I'm uncertain on the foal and aussie's demand..

--

Item, C$ and pet trade
Is this fair/what would need to be added to make it fair? Thank you in advance for any advice!

I think it's unfair to you, the items were all free releases and early rares don't trade as well as older rares. Really it's up to you, but your store dog is worth 30-35 C$, or an early 2010 rare. So it's not too far from fair.

what does the marionette go for these days, with demand?

is this a good offer?

thank you!

I'm going to say no.. most marionettes have been reaching sorbets or a little more, I traded a liontail for mine and they deemed that an underpay on my part. ^^'

[morrissey]

thanks for the feedback before! I now have it down to these two bids
bid 1
bid 2
which bid is better? thanks in advance!

they're both overpay, valuing a zodiac dog at an '09 rare. though the 300 c$ is certainly worth more, i find it harder to trade off than a list pet like that. like said before, it's harder to get a list pet with c$ than it is to get it one with another list. it's up to you what you want, really.

[Sali]

Is this fair demand wise? C:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ACV_wQLxw

[tigresplayz]

Hello which trade is worth more demand wise? Which would YOU personally accept. I'm stuck >.<

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qZtfpBHwXA
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IqU2bZT69g

Looking for second opinion :)

[myth;]

Hello which trade is worth more demand wise? Which would YOU personally accept. I'm stuck >.<

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qZtfpBHwXA
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IqU2bZT69g

Looking for second opinion

Arabian Store Horse.

[holodog]

Thank you so much myth + destiny for the help!

Item(total 603) + advent list trade
I'm not 100% confident in my judgement of item worth in C$/pets but this is basically just a "rough draft" trade, so what would need to be added to either side to make this fair?

[osamu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eiYTOOoyBQ
this?