The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[✧ strawberry ✧]

Hello, I read in "the rares list" thread that a non jeweled liontail is worth a red cerb.
I have a dark leopard list pet, which is the main September list pet...would be fair to trade it for the red cerb?

The Red Cerb has big demand and goes for 1.5-2 nons! Some people say it's worth 1 non, but I don't see people who will just take a nons worth!

Then "the rares list guide" thread is wrong?
It is said that 1 non jeweled liontail is worth a red cerb
...maybe without demand?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=112366#p3039993

The 'rares list' doesn't really take demand into account

uuhhh, how does this trade look?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66980715&userid=799286&signature=T9CoHe4LfdJLYokxL3LSlA

[amaterasu_tea]

someone sent me this bid for an auction and i think i might accept it.
(pink patchy september for shima)

can i have some opinions?

[deercat]

Thank you guys!

[dear.chaton]

How is this?
Thank you in advance!

[november!]

How is this?
Thank you in advance!

Id say it's unfair with the Aussie demand wise.
The horses alone I think would be fair. But, I'm not good at trading. I go off looks XD

[ThunderCedar]

The rares list doesn't factor demand, just straight worth.

Actually, the current list factors in demand (it's even stated on the front page), people just like to re-apply it again creating double demand and a big mess on the way. a list that does not factor in demand is being worked on but we don't know when it will be finished. I'm guessing on the new list, the red ceberus will be below the liontails since they are a whole year apart. <:

[GoldenSlumbers]

bid 1

bid 2

for 100C$ bid

bid3

bid 4

bid 5

bid 6

warning C$

[deercat]

The rares list doesn't factor demand, just straight worth.

Actually, the current list factors in demand (it's even stated on the front page), people just like to re-apply it again creating double demand and a big mess on the way. a list that does not factor in demand is being worked on but we don't know when it will be finished. I'm guessing on the new list, the red ceberus will be below the liontails since they are a whole year apart. <:

So my dark leopard can be worth a red cerb?

[smartiez]

Would this have been fair^^
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UAVTfu3mWQ

[dear.chaton]

How is this?
Thank you in advance!

Id say it's unfair with the Aussie demand wise.
The horses alone I think would be fair. But, I'm not good at trading. I go off looks XD

Thank you! May I get a second opinion please?