The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jazzmisty]

How fair is this?

xxx

You don't have to add the item worth

[Eagle's Eye]

Cob web bun+mini gray husky=?
Thanks for any help! I'm just looking to see what I could get with it.
(Also if this is the wrong place to ask, how much could I get for a red rose dog demand wise?)

Cobweb bun=advent tier 1=3-4 2009 rares
Mini gray husky=advent tier 4=5-6 2009 rares
(You can find gap between the tiers on the fourth page of the rare list guide [: )
Together they're worth 8-10 '09 rares, or technically any of these advent tiers
tier 7(7-8 '09 rares)
tier 8(7-8 '09 rares plus a '09 uncommon)
tier 9(8-9 '09 rares)
tier 10(10 '09 rares)

[alpraz0lam]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66760767&userid=894156&signature=UZLByZnJcrYQxmwc8n41jg

I'm currently auctioning my Plains zebra, I currently have this rated a 6/10 but I'm not really sure of that at all, also, what would be fair for him roughly? Thanks c:

Aaand this one also http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yRtVbMuvig

[Eagle's Eye]

this? fixed!

You are overpaying slightly as their cat was exteneded to August 2009 and by value it's worth the three month rule. There's no set demand value so it's up to you and your trading partner to decide how you want to value the cat. Your uncommons don't make a difference here as they're too recent

[alpraz0lam]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66760767&userid=894156&signature=UZLByZnJcrYQxmwc8n41jg

I'm currently auctioning my Plains zebra, I currently have this rated a 6/10 but I'm not really sure of that at all, also, what would be fair for him roughly? Thanks c:

Aaand this one also http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yRtVbMuvig

[Sali]

I also got these 4 Bids for my UR Bee, which one would be fair for the UR Bee?

Bid

Bid

Bid

Bid

The bee is worth 2 nons
#1-The Raven usually goes for a sorbet to a non; I wouldn't take this. The advent bwolf doesn't do anything here
#2-I see zebras usually go for 1-2 nons. I personally would keep the bee as you'd have an easier time trading it off
#3-The zonkey seems to be going for roughly 1-2 nons so it's up to you to decide how you want to value it
#4-Searched through the older posts of this thread and saw people say that the patchwork goes for roughly a nonballon/green toxic tier at most. Both of those tiers are below sorbets. 3 sorbets=a non, so if you follow that, this bid doesn't add up to a non.

You should get second opinions for all of these

Thank you! C:
Can I have a second opinion? C:

[Starlessnight]

Hello, is this fair for both of us? Any help is super appreciated. Thanks!

Lady Boyle's Last Party

[jazzmisty]

How fair is this?

xxx

You don't have to add the item worth

[The Last Raven]

How fair is this?

xxx

You don't have to add the item worth

Unfair to you. The UR 09 dog is 3 tiers higher than the UR ice cat. The other pets don't make up the difference.

[Wayward Sister]

Could anyone help me out and tell me what I could get with a red rose dog, with demand at most?