The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Corey Taylor]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66750913&userid=781126&signature=lgZqO4SJzG140N80ie37bg

Fair??

[ruel]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BG7ED5QTLQ

Fair?

[vein]

Is this fair?
I'm really not good with trades involving C$.

[pidge gunderson]

could i get a few opinions on these trades?
1) the ur peach gets me every time
2) quantity of staff and items is great
3) im dying for the wigs and green toxic
4) the list and item quantity is jarringly great
5) this demand is amazing
thank you so much to everyone who helps.

also for ren hana:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WB2yLIP4IQ


is this fair? what should be added or changed? thank you

[Mysterious~]

Is the UR Banana fair for my UR Lion demand wise?

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BG7ED5QTLQ

Fair?

Unfair to you
The store pet is only worth an early 2010 rare, your dog is worth a mid-late 09 rare
The 2016 pet on their side doesn't change anything

[LemonadeQueen]

How far off from fair is this? Thanks!! <3

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rtmo5hZ7GQ

I think it is atleast, because A lot of the pets have high demand, and your Moonswirl is a rerelase so it is devalued and I thinnk the C$ help make up for mssin pets.

Please do not give false advice. Rerelease doesn't devalue the pet at all.

Moonswirl = Four Nons

Their side:
UR Cat = 2 Non Dogs + 2 Sorbets
Cinnabun = I believe 1 - 2 Non dogs worth (It isn't placed so there is no "for sure" value. I am just going off what I have heard.)
Other Pets : 2 Mid Advents (Roughly)
CS = Pink Striped September Tier.

Total Worth :
Low End: 3 Non Dogs + 2 Sorbet + 1 High September
High End: 4 Non Dogs + 2 Sorbet + 1 High September

This does not include demand as I am unfamiliar with the demand of the pets. Please get a second opinion for that

EDIT:

Is this fair? Just keep in mind that the egg is a re-release. (2010 I think?)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vFx3PSbtIg

Unfair to you. Their side is only worth a '13 Rare.

Thanks so much!!!! <3

[Lucikan]

Is the UR Banana fair for my UR Lion demand wise?

Demand is user based, however personally I would keep the UR Lion as it tends to be easier to trade off than the Banana. I suggest another opinion though (:

[UnicornLover89]

Is this fair? Just keep in mind that the egg is a re-release. (2010 I think?)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vFx3PSbtIg

In my opinion, this is very unfair to you. Most people on CS go by the 2:1 ratio for years. So their side is worth roughly 1 2014 plus 1 2017 Rare. And on your side, Malk wolves are in decent demand, but even without taking demand into consideration, this is an unfair trade to you. Personally I would edit (drastically) or cancel. Hope this helps!

[Saddened]

Is the UR Banana fair for my UR Lion demand wise?

Demand wise is a definite no,since many people dislike the UR fruits and they tend to go for underpay then a fair trade.although rarity wise there's a huge gap between the two.But i highly agree the lion is much easier to trade off than the fruit.