The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[fluffy tea]

]is this fair?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ZvjkJruZg

[Aeryn]

Should i take this trade?
xx

[vjg321]

i was wondering if this was fair or if if they are underpaying, how much would they need to add..?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... doUcJyT-Rw

[~Journey~]

Is this fair? Demand wise? Thanks!


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 429lDzaiYw

[fluffy tea]

]is this fair?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ZvjkJruZg

[Gordon]

Should I take this? What can my UR Bengal get?

Or maybe this offer for my Bengal?

And should I take this light heart rat for my mid advent and rares? I know it has bad demand but idk...

Trade 1: Unfair to the other side by roughly a green toxic + red rose if I counted right
Although with re-added demand, I've personally seen the bengal go for overpay, though I'm not sure how much. Up to you if you want to take it.
Trade 2: Up to you how you value the bengal demand wise, list wise the nonballoon can swap fairly. They're overpaying by roughly a dark leopard tier + the C$ (which is worth about a mid september list)
Trade 3: The light heart rat is worth about 5 mid advents, your side is worth 1 + a low advent. They're asking for less than half of the rat's worth. Though rats are quite difficult to trade off with most people, so its up to you once again.

More opinions?

[z i m]

should I take it, and can I trade down the coontail fairly?

I'm unsure of the coontail's demand, but I've personally never seen the raven go for any more than a non or the occasional UR lion. I would personally take the trade because of this, but please get a second opinion c:

thank
one more opinion?

[Horror]

is this fair?

Just 3 2014 commons would be about fair if their unknowns become common
Although until we know what rarities the pets get it will be hard to tell, but regardless it will likely be very unfair to you

[bookshelf]

should I take it, and can I trade down the coontail fairly?

I'm unsure of the coontail's demand, but I've personally never seen the raven go for any more than a non or the occasional UR lion. I would personally take the trade because of this, but please get a second opinion c:

thank
one more opinion?

I agree, even if you can't get the full value out of the coontail, you're going to still be able to get more out of it than a raven.

[Rusticsmile67]

is this fair?

Just 3 2014 commons would be about fair if their unknowns become common
Although until we know what rarities the pets get it will be hard to tell, but regardless it will likely be very unfair to you

Without knowing the rarity of the two pets, what about for the others on their side?