The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eagle's Eye]

Is this fair? If not what do I add? I don't really care about demand.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lhuKaF4t_w

Unfair to you, their side is worth 3 '16 uncommons. Your side is worth 8 '16 uncommons

[Farewell!]

Is this fair? If not what do I add? I don't really care about demand.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lhuKaF4t_w

Unfair to you, their side is worth 3 '16 uncommons. Your side is worth 8 '16 uncommons

Thanks.

[zamatsenga]

is this fair? I've had a lot of offers for him..Idk
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VR7NVq6jbw

[Shadow2204]

UR Grapes for UR Mint Horse?

The UR Mint horse overpaid.
Both have low demand so demand doesn't really matter in this trade so going by rarity, the UR Mint horse definitely overpaid. You could get more than what the grapes could get with underpay.

is this fair? I've had a lot of offers for him..Idk
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66323781&userid=886698&signature=l3U712dIjGzWVR7NVq6jbw

Unfair to you.
They're only offering around a little less than half his worth (around there, not sure exactly). In addition, the cat goes for overpay with demand.

[beignet]

is this fair?

[Shadow2204]

is this fair?

I would say unfair to the UR Peach since it goes for 1-2 sorbets with demand while their side isn't worth a sorbet.

[cosmic-quark]

Is this fair? Any help appreciated! <3

[Shadow2204]

Is this fair? Any help appreciated! <3

A early 2010 rare is worth 25-30C$ so the C$ is overpaying by 10-15C$

[da,]

is this fair?

I would say unfair to the UR Peach since it goes for 1-2 sorbets with demand while their side isn't worth a sorbet.

I disagree, their side has a Dragon PPS, which can go for a sorbet by demand alone. Plus, bulk can be valued high.

[ThunderCedar]

is this fair?

I would say unfair to the UR Peach since it goes for 1-2 sorbets with demand while their side isn't worth a sorbet.

I disagree, their side has a Dragon PPS, which can go for a sorbet by demand alone. Plus, bulk can be valued high.

I'll have to agree about the dragon PPS. It can go for pretty high prices as it's in high demand. But anyway trying to price this trade is just a shot in the dark since we don't really have any idea what the peach is worth