The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Kyar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=65848735&userid=872480&signature=33lJIgVAzRRDPyqaA1jYeQ
How about this one?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L5NbLy0hhA
And this, demand wise?

1. Ah… I would say it's reasonable? It's a little tough with the broken set of the rat items - their BW is worth a mid 2009 rare so while I don't think it's out of the realm of a decent offer I'm not 100% positive it's QUITE enough. I'd get a couple of opinions. :)
2. That would be a pretty good offer I think - considering the cat is worth roughly double the punk dog. :) Demand varies so much it's impossible to say exactly - but I would consider that a fairly reasonable offer for both sides all in all. :)

Thank you Kyar ^.^ I've always wanted to have an above gap and two main lists at once so it was two birds with one stone! Besides I'm pretty sure the red toxic has good demand so I think I can get something good for it. I sent their trade back and asked for the Red Tox before I accepted the other one and they sent it back as accept saying they liked it! I'm so happy rn and ty for confirming me and making me feel like I got the good deal! Have a great day!!!

Happy to help! :) I'm so glad it all worked out!

Can anyone help out with this?

That would be unfair to you - their side is worth in the area of a 2012-2013 rare and yours is worth a mid 2009 rare. :)

[asymphony]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=65848735&userid=872480&signature=33lJIgVAzRRDPyqaA1jYeQ
How about this one?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L5NbLy0hhA
And this, demand wise?

1. Ah… I would say it's reasonable? It's a little tough with the broken set of the rat items - their BW is worth a mid 2009 rare so while I don't think it's out of the realm of a decent offer I'm not 100% positive it's QUITE enough. I'd get a couple of opinions.
2. That would be a pretty good offer I think - considering the cat is worth roughly double the punk dog. Demand varies so much it's impossible to say exactly - but I would consider that a fairly reasonable offer for both sides all in all.

Thank you Kyar ^.^ I've always wanted to have an above gap and two main lists at once so it was two birds with one stone! Besides I'm pretty sure the red toxic has good demand so I think I can get something good for it. I sent their trade back and asked for the Red Tox before I accepted the other one and they sent it back as accept saying they liked it! I'm so happy rn and ty for confirming me and making me feel like I got the good deal! Have a great day!!!

Happy to help! I'm so glad it all worked out!

Can anyone help out with this?

That would be unfair to you - their side is worth in the area of a 2012-2013 rare and yours is worth a mid 2009 rare.

Thank you so much! I will think what can we do with second offer ^^ You really hepled me!

[ruthless]

Is this unfair?

I don't think it is fair, because the true date is an 09 dog. I need second opinions.

[Vilhelm]

Is this unfair?

I don't think it is fair, because the true date is an 09 dog. I need second opinions.

Yep! Unfair to you.

[Reirin]

Is this fair? Thanks!

[ivysnap]

sent as a suggestion, should i edit or send it back as is?

[ScarDolphin]

Is this a fair trade?

[Galahad]

what is the butterfly wolf worth? Would you personally accept?

[Kyar]

Is this fair? Thanks!

In terms of rarity they're overpaying slightly but personally I don't know that I would accept this offer considering I've had a lot of impressive offers on the 2013 store pet you've got on your side there along with the fact that generally speaking the light leopard has never had great demand and can be a bit tricky to trade off unless it's part of a larger trade up the list. It's not a bad offer - I'm not sure for me it would be one to jump right at and accept though.

sent as a suggestion, should i edit or send it back as is?

At the moment it's very unfair to them - their side is worth about a mid 2010 rare so depending on how you'd like to edit it I would imagine they're giving you some options to choose from for your pets. :)

Is this a fair trade?

I'd say if you took one of the lions off your side or added about a late 2010 rare to their side that would be a fair trade. :)

[pique]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aCFUqEXJ_w

Im clueless with items! How's this? Thanks so much!

EDIT: this as well! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... e2DG2y6IKQ