The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Nova-Moshi]

Hello! I would like to know if this trade is fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4HbdCyl-jQ

A 2013 common is worth a 2016 rare or two 2017 rares. This is unfair to them because of the age gap

Thank you! Can I have some other input before I decide?

[ivysnap]

this is tripping me up for some reason, i can't figure out if i think it's fair. could i get some help please? C:

[minccino]

this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... U8vvQdN9Hg

They have no rarities yet, so no one can be certain if they're fair or not. It's up to you to decide how you want to value them; they are from the same swap and cost the same.

Alright, thanks

[plisetsky]

thoughts on this, please? thank you!

Personally, i'd take it since they're overpaying by about a blue rose and try to trade the apple for a lower main list or a september list pet worth more than 8 mid advents (your side is worth around 8 mid advents).

But that's personal preference.

thank you so much! second opinion?

[asymphony]

edit: And this? ^^ I'm not good with items haha

no. i dont think items have ever really be worth a store pet beside like the pocky and super old items.
so you are overpaying

thank you! can i get a second opinion?

I would not accept that.The cat is probably going to be a common-uncommon,and even if it's a rare,a 2017 rare wouldn't be worth 4 possibly very rares [which are worth 4 09 rares at least.] and that item is I believe a april fools day item.

This item is on rare items list, its from aprin fools day 2009 ^^
But is this more fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... w33G6mDy7Q
These items are on list too c:

[friends dønt lie.]

Is this fair? I don't know how much demand these pets have. Thanks for your help!

[meged321]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Xxh0v1gqog

[ThunderCedar]

Is this fair? I don't know how much demand these pets have. Thanks for your help!

nowhere near fair. your angel advent is worth 7 mid advents. their pets aren't rare or in demand enough to add up to that.

[dear.chaton]

Which of these two is most fair? one two

[puckish]

Pretty sure they're overpaying but I don't know what tokens are going for right now? Any help is appreciated; thank you in advance!

I'm pretty sure they're overpaying by alot.The dinosaur plushies also go for alot from what i've seen.Though i'd reccomend a second opinion as everyone values tokens differently.

@Kylinq
Thank you <3

Thank you! Could I get a second opinion?