2017 Summer Event - Casual Chat V.2 [read first post]

[Jodjo]

Evidence for Chef Calamari being behind the instruments.

EVIDENCE:

REASONING:

• Weapons: Shells and seaweed. What did Chef Calamari need today? Thats right. for his "famous Salty Salad".
• "Did you see the news today? They're acting like no crime ever happens here. What about all the sticky paws helping themselves to my grub? I need a vacation." He is obviously upset that critters were eating his food, maybe he was hoping to gain a vacation from postponing the jamboree by sabotaging it.
• Orchid Sprig tentacles: his mane is made of tentacles! Plus he could have used some of the squid he has on the table to frame Panopea or the head guard himself! an orchid sprig.

relating it to Raire's hints:

• He gave us food such as shish kabobs and pink pudding. Not to mention he need the kelp and shells for his salty salad.

EVIDENCE CON'T

• "working late swatting thieves away from my food" but the otters weren't there in the first place..?! A false scapegoat. If he was there late, he had plenty of an opportunity to trash the instruments.

dang i'm going to argue with people over pixel pets

oKAY but shelly has also been asking for shells and seaweed, and at that, wAY before chef calamari wanted them.

i personally think raire's hints point to shelly - in that hint, raire also mentioned she has room for two more meals, and shelly is the one who wanted food - she wants twO food items.

i don't think that the otters are always the thieves - i mean to say that they are the only thieves in the lost city is kinda,,, unreasonable in my opinion - also, how do we know we adopted all of the otters?? maybe the chef didn't catch all of the otters and some escaped??

the tentacle thing was a nice detail, though!! kinda forgot about the tentacle thing. it could have been cuttler inspecting the stage afterwards, though.

the pinboard shows that "we love cuttler" but is this another ploy to make us think cuttler is sweet but yet they destroyed everything?

[nickjr]

"Oh, did I forget to mention my specialty is body painting?"

YES YOU DID MY JAW ACTUALLY DROPPED BECAUSE I WAS EXPECTING ITEMS OR SOMETHING AND YOU HANDED ME THOSE GORGEOUS PETS DAAAAAAAAAAAAAANG.

"Use a piece of cute stationery to record your interview with Chef Calamari!"
"cute stationery to record your interview"

That's an oddly specific and atmosphere-discompliant command LOL


omg this is golden
"WANTED: fooooood"

[Sketchasaur]

Everyone is trying to figure out who the culprit is but I'm over here like


"No-one gonna talk about how good that food looks??"

I dunno, that taco looks a little fishy

Jello is spot on mhm
I really want the jello out of all the food <33

[MacabreLion]

My cat has decided to join the investigation I guess.
Right when I try to post or type he just decided to lay on the phone, and what tab does he open?
None other than the pearl game
And who is that run by?
Panopea, aka my least favorite npc lmao
She's guilty.

[lady gaga]

Evidence for Chef Calamari being behind the instruments.

EVIDENCE:

REASONING:

• Weapons: Shells and seaweed. What did Chef Calamari need today? Thats right. for his "famous Salty Salad".
• "Did you see the news today? They're acting like no crime ever happens here. What about all the sticky paws helping themselves to my grub? I need a vacation." He is obviously upset that critters were eating his food, maybe he was hoping to gain a vacation from postponing the jamboree by sabotaging it.
• Orchid Sprig tentacles: his mane is made of tentacles! Plus he could have used some of the squid he has on the table to frame Panopea or the head guard himself! an orchid sprig.

relating it to Raire's hints:

• He gave us food such as shish kabobs and pink pudding. Not to mention he need the kelp and shells for his salty salad.

EVIDENCE CON'T

• "working late swatting thieves away from my food" but the otters weren't there in the first place..?! A false scapegoat. If he was there late, he had plenty of an opportunity to trash the instruments.

dang i'm going to argue with people over pixel pets

oKAY but shelly has also been asking for shells and seaweed, and at that, wAY before chef calamari wanted them.

i personally think raire's hints point to shelly - in that hint, raire also mentioned she has room for two more meals, and shelly is the one who wanted food - she wants twO food items.

i don't think that the otters are always the thieves - i mean to say that they are the only thieves in the lost city is kinda,,, unreasonable in my opinion - also, how do we know we adopted all of the otters?? maybe the chef didn't catch all of the otters and some escaped??

the tentacle thing was a nice detail, though!! kinda forgot about the tentacle thing. it could have been cuttler inspecting the stage afterwards, though.

the pinboard shows that "we love cuttler" but is this another ploy to make us think cuttler is sweet but yet they destroyed everything?

plot twist, cutler put that sticky note there himself

[holocryptic]

Everyone is trying to figure out who the culprit is but I'm over here like


"No-one gonna talk about how good that food looks??"

I dunno, that taco looks a little fishy

ba tum tss

ok but fr it looks rlly good

I know right? Like just chill m8s and eat some good food from the FREAKING AMAZING LION CHEF-

[SillyStrings]

Everyone is trying to figure out who the culprit is but I'm over here like


"No-one gonna talk about how good that food looks??"

I dunno, that taco looks a little fishy

ba tum tss

ok but fr it looks rlly good

sorry for the horrible pun, but their are so many opper-tuna-ties to make puns i couldnt kelp myself

[Jodjo]

I dunno, that taco looks a little fishy

ba tum tss

ok but fr it looks rlly good

sorry for the horrible pun, but their are so many opper-tuna-ties to make puns i couldnt kelp myself

you must be the theif because you keep breaking the law with these outrageous puns

[lady gaga]

-snip-
edit: we only gave calamari the shells & seaweed today which probably isn't enough to literally break a ton of instrumenrs but we've been giving shelly shells & seaweed right from the start

yes, but if he committed the crime overnight and wasted all his materials, wouldn't he need more to make food so you could give them to the Boutique?

[cryptid.]

Everyone is trying to figure out who the culprit is but I'm over here like


"No-one gonna talk about how good that food looks??"

I dunno, that taco looks a little fishy

ba tum tss

ok but fr it looks rlly good

sorry for the horrible pun, but their are so many opper-tuna-ties to make puns i couldnt kelp myself[/quote]

this is punishment for us