"The" Rares List Guide - Do not ask about new UR's!

[Hekomi]

Should the Black Advent, BMD and angel Advent be added to the September list? (Focusing on the BA in paticular) They've been worth Septembers for months.

It has been noted that the top tier of the advents is worth Septembers.

(note that aside from the first few lines, there is a significant gap in worth between these and the September '08 pets)

-- Jeweled

[huskynerd]

Really? o_0 That's exactly where I would've placed the White Dragon.

[Kevinsaurus]

I'm pretty sure the white dragon is worth around like a pink september. Not sure if it's worth up to the floppy pink's value =s, might be just the patchy / striped ones. But it's definitely not worth a dark leopard =x.

[Hekomi]

Really? o_0 That's exactly where I would've placed the White Dragon.

Thissss.

-- Jeweled

[BrightPink]

Definitely not. White dragon is not worth that much.

Really? o_0 That's exactly where I would've placed the White Dragon.

No wonder I get no offers when I listen to deja xD
lol, joke, you know more about rarities more than me anyway.

I don't want it to be worth that little ;(

[Diabolic]

I think the september list needs a little bit of a revamp actually.

As it is now it reflects rarity most I'd say, but not actual popularity value.
The Red X is far above the cakedogs in popularity - I'd almost be willing to
place it right under the Dark Leopard. I'd say the blue rose is above the cakedogs
too, and that the cakedogs seem to me like they go for at most a pink sept. these days.

As for the white dragon, I personally think it is worth somewhere around a floppy pink sept,
or a blue rose. Paying a Dark leopard for it sounds like a massive rip-off to me : x

[Seasonal]

I agree with moving the Blue Rose above the Cake Dogs. The Blue Rose is much more popular.

[La Roux'd]

I agree. No one is willing to trade their blue rose for a cake dog. I never expected the white dragon to be at the dark leopard. I think the floppy pink is a good estimated value for the dragon. Eventhough i can't find anyone willing to offer a fair amount for it anyways. :[

[huskynerd]

Pudding that is considered spam, please use the "bookmark" tool.

And I dunno, guys, I just don't agree. The only difference in rarity between the white dragon and the blue one is 1 day (the advent '09 rerelease). Do people really dislike the design that much? With the Cake Dogs, I'm not sure I would agree with moving them down. I wonder if they suffer from being referred to as a whole, because of course you're gonna see more if you're referring to all 5 outcomes instead of them individually. Like, there's only one Blue Rose and Red X dog. I dunno, I consider the Cake Dogs to be fairly high value Septembers.

How big is he gap between growing july, and BEG?

About one VR September '08.

[Diabolic]

Pudding that is considered spam, please use the "bookmark" tool.

And I dunno, guys, I just don't agree. The only difference in rarity between the white dragon and the blue one is 1 day (the advent '09 rerelease). Do people really dislike the design that much? With the Cake Dogs, I'm not sure I would agree with moving them down. I wonder if they suffer from being referred to as a whole, because of course you're gonna see more if you're referring to all 5 outcomes instead of them individually. Like, there's only one Blue Rose and Red X dog. I dunno, I consider the Cake Dogs to be fairly high value Septembers.

I refer to them as a whole because they suffer from the Grinner symptom - there is
a value difference, but no one really cares about it C;

Cakedogs are aslajkfhadjk so hard to get rid of. No one ever picks them out
of my trades. All the other septembers, sure. Blue rose, red rose, Red X, heck even
the target dog goes before the cakedogs when it comes to bulk trades.

The only reason you see them in trades really is when people a) Trade for C$ b) When
people with very little trading fodder are trying to trade for something better - the cakedogs
are usually the one VR they have, because they are so easy to find and get a hold of
due to how little interest people have in them.

They are valuable, but let's face it - peope will much rather have mysterious dark pets
with rose vines all over them, or three tailed badass X dogs with piercings and claws.
Dogs that are on fire and covered in icing sorta fail on that aspect xD