The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64326077&userid=243000&signature=oi7biK03-9JL6dzU2iy1QA


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g31uKXT_sg



which one should I accept??

Even with demand the pps malk is not even close to the worth of 2 grinners. The pps is really only worth 3-4 09 rares. Just one grinned is worth 2 mid advents and a 09 rare (13-16 09 rares).

Just saw the second one. I would definitely not pay that much for a shima LT. Demand varies by person but even then the most they have been going for is a mid advent (up to 8 09 rares).

An add on to the shima trade: Demand is on and off. The shima's demand can drop at any moment. Remember, without demand the grinners could get way more than a shima can get since a shima is only worth another '09 rare within 3 months of it's orginal release.

[watery>~<]

what about this one for a grevy ? my ultimate goal is a sunjewel so I'm really stuck aaa, thank you!

Personally, I would take this, UR Cucumbers are nearly impossible to trade off (because it has awful demand and most people don't want something with bad demand and is extremely hard to trade off) and tribals also have bad demand. Of course rarity wise, this is unfair to you, but demand wise 2 bad/horrible demand pets for a meh demand pet that normally goes for fair trades? But, the UR Bengal Cat you have there can go for massive overpay. So at the same time it may be a disadvantage to you

[Fwutter]

what about this one for a grevy ? my ultimate goal is a sunjewel so I'm really stuck aaa, thank you!

Personally, I would take this, UR Cucumbers are nearly impossible to trade off (because it has awful demand and most people don't want something with bad demand and is extremely hard to trade off) and tribals also have bad demand. Of course rarity wise, this is unfair to you, but demand wise 2 bad/horrible demand pets for a meh demand pet that normally goes for fair trades? But, the UR Bengal Cat you have there can go for massive overpay. So at the same time it may be a disadvantage to you

I agree. The pets they are asking for have really bad demand and most of the time go for half or even 1/3 of what they are worth so I would take this. Demand does vary and it is up to you if you want to take it or not.

[~SpotOnAppy~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64326584&userid=309782&signature=7RNHvx0RpiVcETvsjkdKzQ

Help please

[kayxcore]

Hey, is this a fair trade?
trade

[fidlar]

x
as the red x is a list pet, would my side of the trade cover the gap?

[Fwutter]

x
as the red x is a list pet, would my side of the trade cover the gap?

I don't necessarily know what you mean but you need to add 5 more mid advents for it to be fair.

[Stilinski_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/s ... d=64327019
I'm doing a lil' gifting war, but I'm unsure if any of us were being unfair.
I did add a Love penpen red, but I removed it since they only added 2 background which I could get for a few uncommon pets.

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/sharetrade.php?id=64327019
I'm doing a lil' gifting war, but I'm unsure if any of us were being unfair.
I did add a Love penpen red, but I removed it since they only added 2 background which I could get for a few uncommon pets.

You didn't copy the link properly, we can't see it. Go to the top of the page and click [share link]

[Stilinski_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/sharetrade.php?id=64327019
I'm doing a lil' gifting war, but I'm unsure if any of us were being unfair.
I did add a Love penpen red, but I removed it since they only added 2 background which I could get for a few uncommon pets.

You didn't copy the link properly, we can't see it. Go to the top of the page and click [share link]

Oh oops, I do that every time.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/s ... d=64327044
One of these? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xUxNmfridQ