The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[LemonadeQueen]

Is this fair? Thanks!

Also, how many mid advents is the Pink flop ear dog (sept list) worth? Ty

Dog:

[ser]

tysm for your reply!
what about these? are any fair, and if so, which one would be the fairest?
x
x

first one is a fair tier swap
second adds up to about 14 '09 rares, which is 2 midadvents, which is still unfair

[kaeria]

tysm for your reply!
what about these? are any fair, and if so, which one would be the fairest?
x
x

first one is a fair tier swap
second adds up to about 14 '09 rares, which is 2 midadvents, which is still unfair

thanks! if anybody has a second opinion that'd be great , just to check before i cancel or accept.
also for the first one is my pet or theres higher in demand or equal? because i've heard mine isn't great but if there's is higher in demand i would really like that.

[Sali]

If I were to receive this, I wouldn't take it. The Red Cerb and UR Lion can easily be swapped since both go for around a non (that's what I've seen people offering). The Grinner, depending on the user, may be able to be swapped for the Patchwork but I've seen people offering more mid-high septembers with decent demand for them. The added pets dont cover what I've seen the BA go for (around a sorbet).

Thank you, how much would be needed to add? Would a Blue Malk PPS dragon may cover the gap? C:

I mean, it depends on the user. I forgot to mention that I've seen the Red Cerb go for aroun d 1-2 nons, so if the user values their red cerb at 2 nons, then even adding the BA wouldn't be enough for the red cerb. But varying on the person, a malk pps dragon can go for around 2-4 balloon dogs and I've seen people valuing the BA at around 4 balloon dogs (a sorbet). So yes, possibly, depending on the user.

Can I have a second opinion? I aslo would have a Yellow Toxic that I could add as well c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -6kLaigqow

[snowdrake]

[quoe="Sali"]

If I were to receive this, I wouldn't take it. The Red Cerb and UR Lion can easily be swapped since both go for around a non (that's what I've seen people offering). The Grinner, depending on the user, may be able to be swapped for the Patchwork but I've seen people offering more mid-high septembers with decent demand for them. The added pets dont cover what I've seen the BA go for (around a sorbet).

Thank you, how much would be needed to add? Would a Blue Malk PPS dragon may cover the gap? C:

I mean, it depends on the user. I forgot to mention that I've seen the Red Cerb go for aroun d 1-2 nons, so if the user values their red cerb at 2 nons, then even adding the BA wouldn't be enough for the red cerb. But varying on the person, a malk pps dragon can go for around 2-4 balloon dogs and I've seen people valuing the BA at around 4 balloon dogs (a sorbet). So yes, possibly, depending on the user.

Can I have a second opinion? I aslo would have a Yellow Toxic that I could add as well c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -6kLaigqow[/quote]

Can I have a second opinion? I aslo would have a Yellow Toxic that I could add as well c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -6kLaigqow

taking demand into account you should at least add a non to your side. their side is worth 581 mid advents, your's is worth roughly 330 mid advents.

I gave you an answer on the last page.

[Squishie~]

I need help fast lol how is this?

[snowdrake]

I need help fast lol how is this?

very unfair to you. they have to add a line tribal to make it fair.

[.:Viv:.]

Hello! Is this fair rarity wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hzj6VglfYA
Thank you for any help!

[kaeria]

tysm for your reply!
what about these? are any fair, and if so, which one would be the fairest?
x
x

first one is a fair tier swap
second adds up to about 14 '09 rares, which is 2 midadvents, which is still unfair

thanks! if anybody has a second opinion that'd be great , just to check before i cancel or accept.
also for the first one is my pet or theres higher in demand or equal? because i've heard mine isn't great but if there's is higher in demand i would really like that.

[Astrophei]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64316963&userid=850362&signature=TnMq5fK6qgKa_0IJxvLbaQ ?