The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kaeria]

is this fair, or unfair?
xxx

unfair to you; your cake dog is a mid september worth about 6 mid advents
their side is only worth 2 '09 rares + a late '10 rare + some older uncommons/doesn't add up to even a first tier advent

tysm for your reply!
what about these? are any fair, and if so, which one would be the fairest?
x
x

[Astrophei]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64316963&userid=850362&signature=TnMq5fK6qgKa_0IJxvLbaQ ?

[Kittehhcat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64316493&userid=868440&signature=tVJRYjR22T_yujhwOd8fTw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZZTi6CqN4w

? If it's not fair, what would they have to add? What would I have to add?

Second one I feel like it's VERY unfair to you. I'm not sure if your dog is a list pet, but those are all store pets they're offering you with 2 normal rares I think. Probably need another opinion, but second one seems very unfair.

[Sali]

If I were to receive this, I wouldn't take it. The Red Cerb and UR Lion can easily be swapped since both go for around a non (that's what I've seen people offering). The Grinner, depending on the user, may be able to be swapped for the Patchwork but I've seen people offering more mid-high septembers with decent demand for them. The added pets dont cover what I've seen the BA go for (around a sorbet).

Thank you, how much would be needed to add? Would a Blue Malk PPS dragon may cover the gap? C:

I mean, it depends on the user. I forgot to mention that I've seen the Red Cerb go for aroun d 1-2 nons, so if the user values their red cerb at 2 nons, then even adding the BA wouldn't be enough for the red cerb. But varying on the person, a malk pps dragon can go for around 2-4 balloon dogs and I've seen people valuing the BA at around 4 balloon dogs (a sorbet). So yes, possibly, depending on the user.

Can I have a second opinion? I aslo would have a Yellow Toxic that I could add as well c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -6kLaigqow

[Katskatskats]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64311568&userid=825453&signature=fJKSaXiZpwtrGJY6HokpAA

Is this fair? For an omgsr zebra?

How much would need to be added to make it fair?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ujhwOd8fTw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZZTi6CqN4w

? If it's not fair, what would they have to add? What would I have to add?

Second one I feel like it's VERY unfair to you. I'm not sure if your dog is a list pet, but those are all store pets they're offering you with 2 normal rares I think. Probably need another opinion, but second one seems very unfair.

1. Unfair to you. The grinners add up to 4 mid advents and your side is worth about 4.5 mid advents. They could add a low advent or replace your sock dog with a mid advent

2. Also unfair to you. The husky is worth about 4 mid 09 rares, they are only offering about 2 late 09 rares

[snowdrake]

Can I have a second opinion? I aslo would have a Yellow Toxic that I could add as well c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -6kLaigqow

taking demand into account you should at least add a non to your side. their side is worth 581 mid advents, your's is worth roughly 330 mud advents.

[jazzmisty]

Hi! How fair is this? Thank you in advance!

[kaeria]

tysm for your reply!
what about these? are any fair, and if so, which one would be the fairest?
x
x

[myth;]

How does this trade look? Should I leave it be or cancel before they make their move?