The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Hauntednightmares]

Should I accept? I value cinnabon at a non. How much must be added if it's not fair. Keep demand in mind of malk dragons

[mountain tree]

Is this pet worth -----> http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=3209633
This pet? ------->. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=6773196

Bump

both are worth the three month rule (meaning they are worth another pet- ideally another dog- of the same year and within three months of it's adoption date c: however, the ornament dog is from a christmas event so you could maybe fetch slightly more for him.
edit;; you don't need to re-post/bump your post until it's been a full page or more and you're confident it's been forgotten/unanswered c:

[Hauntednightmares]

Should I accept? I value cinnabon at a non. How much must be added if it's not fair. Keep demand in mind of malk dragons

[hongjoongie.]

is this fair? if not, what should be done to make it fair? thank you in advance! pineapple101

[mew,]

this trade i got confuses me a little. Is it fair?
If not, what would I/they need to add?
Thank you for your opinions!

[Siki]

Hiyo I would truly like some help on this before closing up my auction. Thank you for the help and your time!
[ trade ]

[gudetama]

this trade i got confuses me a little. Is it fair?
If not, what would I/they need to add?
Thank you for your opinions!

correct me if im wrong but, I wouldnt accept because a 2008-9 very rare is worth two 09 rares and a 10 rare. they are just giving you three '10s and who knows what the items are worth?

[pink]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mKNa4pGNUg
Would this be fair for their UR Cinnabun? If not what would be needed to be taken away or added? Please take demand into consideration.
(edit sorry wrong trade fixed it now)

[Hauntednightmares]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64027456&userid=781977&signature=OyCF7BcMoexYmKNa4pGNUg
Would this be fair for their UR Cinnabun? If not what would be needed to be taken away or added? Please take demand into consideration.
(edit sorry wrong trade fixed it now)

Yes I'm on the other end.

[The Last Raven]

this trade i got confuses me a little. Is it fair?
If not, what would I/they need to add?
Thank you for your opinions!

correct me if im wrong but, I wouldnt accept because a 2008-9 very rare is worth two 09 rares and a 10 rare. they are just giving you three '10s and who knows what the items are worth?

Unfair to you. An early 09 very rare is worth 2 early 09 rares and their side only adds up to an 09 rare and a 2010 rare. They would need to add another early 2010 rare if this trade were only for the dog. but the wolf plushies is worth a mid 09 rare. So they would need to add either: A) a 2010 early rare and a mid 09 rare or B) remove a 2010 rare and add a early 09 rare and a mid 09 rare.