The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Guest]

Would a Malk Mutant be fair for a Shima?

[spacecatmint]

Ah okay thank you guys for your help :p
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jJkHKH21UA
Could i also please have help with this?

it's perfectly fair as a 2010 very rare is worth a 2009 rare, and they are both October c:

[zenzi]

Would a Malk Mutant be fair for a Shima?

in the past the shima was more popular (even though both pets went for pretty big stuff) but now i'd say its more or less even. just depends on your personal preference

[Mavi]

What do you guys think on this?

[zenzi]

What do you guys think on this?

mm kinda tricky, there are a lot of factors to consider on both sides.
generally it would benefit you in the long term with the malk pps due to their demand (on average i've received a sorb - purple toxic offers on mine) and the pets on your side don't tend to fetch as much.
although, there is indeed decent demand list quantity on your side so it depends if you'd prefer that quantity over just having 1 pet.
personally i wouldn't do this though, just because i know how hard it is to obtain or even see a brown sleipnir so i wouldn't be bothered going through that process again.

[kiono]

What do you think about it?

[Mavi]

What do you guys think on this?

mm kinda tricky, there are a lot of factors to consider on both sides.
generally it would benefit you in the long term with the malk pps due to their demand (on average i've received a sorb - purple toxic offers on mine) and the pets on your side don't tend to fetch as much.
although, there is indeed decent demand list quantity on your side so it depends if you'd prefer that quantity over just having 1 pet.
personally i wouldn't do this though, just because i know how hard it is to obtain or even see a brown sleipnir so i wouldn't be bothered going through that process again.

Thank you very much for your help, do you happen to know what the Sleipnir is going for on its own? I usually do off-site trades to get my store list pets so I am way out of the loop on this one

[zenzi]

What do you guys think on this?

mm kinda tricky, there are a lot of factors to consider on both sides.
generally it would benefit you in the long term with the malk pps due to their demand (on average i've received a sorb - purple toxic offers on mine) and the pets on your side don't tend to fetch as much.
although, there is indeed decent demand list quantity on your side so it depends if you'd prefer that quantity over just having 1 pet.
personally i wouldn't do this though, just because i know how hard it is to obtain or even see a brown sleipnir so i wouldn't be bothered going through that process again.

Thank you very much for your help, do you happen to know what the Sleipnir is going for on its own? I usually do off-site trades to get my store list pets so I am way out of the loop on this one

can't really give you an estimate currently (going back to my point about how they're so hard to find haha)
in my most recent attempts i offered a green toxic, a red toxic, a balloon dog+ some quantity and none of those offers were accepted.
hopefully that will give you kind of an idea, but then again it can depend on the person!

What do you think about it?

unfair to you, the gap between the non and the lion is roughly a green toxic.
the butterbun is worth a green toxic + nonballoon

[kiono]

What do you think about it?

unfair to you, the gap between the non and the lion is roughly a green toxic.
the butterbun is worth a green toxic + nonballoon

Ty very much <3

[angelo]

this?