The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[.crossfire.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7ddgA-QTzQ

What can be removed or added

[Obius]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xUFcbe7w5Q

Was this a fair offer?

[sluiceway]

Is this fair with demand?

edit;;
also : Is a Coontail fair for my '08 UR Cat?

[silverlightcs]

I'm pretty sure this is fair, since the BW is a store pet, but just making sure because I'm not the best at trades.
Here is the link

[employer]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63522187&userid=842198&signature=9ix02PoY1En7fGUx4vJsBA
Help?

[Fwutter]

I'm pretty sure this is fair, since the BW is a store pet, but just making sure because I'm not the best at trades.
Here is the link

Correct me if I'm wrong, but that VR on your side is a 2010 rerelease. So it's unfair to you by another '10 rare, and the 2016 UC definitely doesn't add up to a 2010 rare.

[Jiloon]

I'm pretty sure this is fair, since the BW is a store pet, but just making sure because I'm not the best at trades.
Here is the link

Very unfair to you! Your pet is originally from Easter/early spring 2010, and is worth at least 2-3 2016 store pets c;

[Easterrabbit2]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hebdEEQ2Lw

Is this fair?
What should they add if it's not?

[The Last Raven]

I'm pretty sure this is fair, since the BW is a store pet, but just making sure because I'm not the best at trades.
Here is the link

The store pet is only worth a mid 2010 rare,not a early 2010 very rares. They would need to add a early 2010 rare and a 2010 uncommon to make up the gap between mid and early.

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63475746&userid=806687&signature=xUr00t7mjKarhebdEEQ2Lw

Is this fair?
What should they add if it's not?

Unfair to you, their side is only worth a '11 rare + '15 rare. I'd take off the recent pets on their side and add a '11 rare or 2 more '10 uncommons.