The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Smaug The Dragon]

Hey.
I'm confused on this trade... I know the demand of the Malk dragons are very high, so what do you think? Also my malk dragon is a true date. So here are the questions:
~Is this trade fair (I know it's not but there are questions attched):
1. Demand wise
2. Rarity wise
~What is the demand of the TD grey malk dragon?
~What is the demand of the UR butterbun?
~Would YOU accept this trade?

[Sylvia]

Hey guys, what do you think about this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h5RkFFNtFw

Thank you

[SorakaHeals]

I completely lost the item trade thread, so your opinion on whether this is fair please ^^ I've been asking for ages now x3

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=559754 Unfair to the reindeer plush

[Odasakn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63514940&userid=797289&signature=g0BXqjB_qSYX_GTwiH-8Qg

How much would need to be added or taken away? I'd like to know asap since those are the last zodiacs I need to complete the collection

[Eagle's Eye]

Hey.
I'm confused on this trade... I know the demand of the Malk dragons are very high, so what do you think? Also my malk dragon is a true date. So here are the questions:
~Is this trade fair (I know it's not but there are questions attched):
1. Demand wise
2. Rarity wise
~What is the demand of the TD grey malk dragon?
~What is the demand of the UR butterbun?
~Would YOU accept this trade?

I can only answer a few
I had a Grey Malk dragon auction not that long ago. I received bids (and other trades before I auctioned) offering these:
-exact value of the dragon (8 mid advents)
-apple
-UR purple horse (same tier as apple)
-speckled rat (one tier above the apple and purple horse)
-UR dog for two grey dragons+some other advents and old store pets. If I remember correctly from what someone told me, this was huge overpay value wise. My side was worth roughly 20 mid advents while the UR dog was worth 40+?80+? I can't remember ^^'' Also, the UR dog is one tier below the butterbun
I don't know the demand of the butterbun, but if we look at your side demand wise and their side value wise, this is the best offer I've seen.
This was the offer I ended up taking for my dragon click. They offered roughly 10 mid advents.
I'd personally take this, simply because I think the butterbun is very cute and there is a huge value gap here.
Also, please note that rereleases are worth the same as their true date peers.

[spacecatmint]

I completely lost the item trade thread, so your opinion on whether this is fair please ^^ I've been asking for ages now x3

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=559754 Unfair to the reindeer plush

agreed. the reindeer plush is worth a 08 rare/very rare according to the item thread, and the 2011 store pet is worth 1-2 09 rares c:

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63514940&userid=797289&signature=g0BXqjB_qSYX_GTwiH-8Qg

How much would need to be added or taken away? I'd like to know asap since those are the last zodiacs I need to complete the collection

Tier 4=5-6 2009 rares. If you guys value a Zodiac as a '09 rare each (which a lot of people do), this is roughly fair. Also please don't sound so hurried, the people helping here don't like to be rushed.

[bananer]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8z-7JgJdAA

How muc chickendollars would fill this gap for the bengal?
thank yoooou!

[casper.]

Trade

Opinions?

[Odasakn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63514940&userid=797289&signature=g0BXqjB_qSYX_GTwiH-8Qg

How much would need to be added or taken away? I'd like to know asap since those are the last zodiacs I need to complete the collection

Tier 4=5-6 2009 rares. If you guys value a Zodiac as a '09 rare each (which a lot of people do), this is roughly fair. Also please don't sound so hurried, the people helping here don't like to be rushed.

Ah so sorry! I didnt want to keep them waiting much longer but thanks ヽ(；▽；)ノ second opinion?