The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[RainWingThing]

@ the argument above. The spider is not a tier one advent. The trade was fair ?????

And @Fwutter you said it was fair and now you're saying it's not?

[Ally12345]

I'll msg them first see what the person says

well if u dont feel good about your trade, u can ask them if they can doa trade back. hope u get it sloved

[세레비]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63511896&userid=870724&signature=2YA3e1cB-8_tL1e23sSqVA? How's the trade now

that looks fair to me

Please stop giving out false advice!
It is not fair and they would have to add 2 more '09 rares for it to be remotely fair as that spider is a tier 1 advent list pet :).

I'm sorry for adding further confusion into this, but I don't think that spider was ever on the list.
I'm pretty sure adding another '09-'10 rare would've been enough to make it a fair rarity swap.

[Legacyy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63511970&userid=870724&signature=fVtqaXfC3LUme1D3zidGkA
Got another trade ^^

[Legacyy]

I'll msg them first see what the person says

well if u dont feel good about your trade, u can ask them if they can doa trade back. hope u get it sloved

They haven't responded yet so I'm moving onto a ticket

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63511970&userid=870724&signature=fVtqaXfC3LUme1D3zidGkA
Got another trade ^^

They're overpaying by an '09 rare, they really only need 2 of them for it to be fair :>

[Joof]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63511896&userid=870724&signature=2YA3e1cB-8_tL1e23sSqVA? How's the trade now

Let me resolve the fairness question on this.
The spider is a regular vr re-release from february '10. It is worth an early '10 very rare or about an early 09 rare. The horse they offer is a late 09 rare. The other two rares add up to an '11 rare (=4 '11 uncommons =2 '10 uncommons) that's not entirely enough to fill the gap, but i'd say another (earlyish) '10 uncommon should make the trade fair. It wasn't that far off rarity wise.
Demand is user based and personal on this one (:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63511970&userid=870724&signature=fVtqaXfC3LUme1D3zidGkA
Got another trade ^^

They're overpaying by an '09 rare, they really only need 2 of them for it to be fair :>

I slightly disagree here. The vr is an early 09 rare while their rares are all mid-late 09. Therefore 2 of the rares, plus a '10 uncommon or two would have been fair.
I agree that it is overpay though (:

[s a g e]

Would this be demand wise fair??

Lolita= balloon dog

[kiro,,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... r1C7A0GhTA I know it's unfair to me but what should be added to their side?

[Shadow2204]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63512267&userid=826971&signature=d7ggcYtwCuKlr1C7A0GhTA I know it's unfair to me but what should be added to their side?

They need to add about 128 2016 uncommons to equal a 2010 uncommon, valuing 2 2016 uc = 1 2015 uc. A 2010 uncommon is also worth about a 2012 rare as well.