The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Krocodalie]

I'm pretty new, so any advice for this trade I received would very much be appreciated!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63507472&userid=873558&signature=kpMDbwgpmcFsDZUdlNJOmQ

[Fallonxi]

Hey there, I'm new to the lists and the Tiers of the advents confuse me a bit...

Is this a fair trade??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... b9-pMginag

Help please ;w;

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63507622&userid=863039&signature=qt4MGv4yiY7opumxvOSGSg

Would this be fair? I'm a huge noob ;U;

Demand wise, no. Warrior cats easily go for more than their worth. That guy could go for a '09 rare

[marshsiren]

Hey, would this be fair? and would you accept it? (contains store pets) thank you c:
Blomp

[Kittysnyper]

Would you guys personally accept this trade? With or without the butterfly wolf.

[dvnc]

Hello! I am rusty on item trades... Any opinions are helpful! x (The nick horse is from 2009)

[Zanadaya]

Would you guys personally accept this trade? With or without the butterfly wolf.

i would personally accept this, C$ has some good demand and you can buy great stuff with it!

[Eagle's Eye]

Hey, would this be fair? and would you accept it? (contains store pets) thank you c:
Blomp

2012 store pet=early 2009 rare
2014 store pet=late 2009 rare
Value wise they're overpaying a bit. The 2016 rare can be ignored here. The husky is from February 2009
I personally would not take this because I collect store pets. Also, the older ones tend to be quite hard to find

[Rogue.She.Wolf]

Is this Bid Fair or overpay?

[serotonin.syringe]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XH5h28Mj1g
should they add?