The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[leiawolfe]

Is this fair? Thank you :3

very unfair to the blue rose, their dog is on the advent list :3

Another opinion?

[ace.of.spades]

Fair yes or no?

Bloop

I don't think it is fair personally, because;
As the red rose pps is a main list and although they are offering the ur ice cat, the cheshire has very high demand which may even lead to be worth more than the ur ice cat. The two bunnies don't help the trade more balanced either.

A red rose pps is worth 11 mid advents. The ice cat is worth about just over 34. The bunnies are both mid advents. The cheshire can go for one with popularity. So unfair to the ice cat.

More opinions?

[Bok Choy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 043G0hga9g

It's me again. Just want to know, is this fair? I'm not very well versed with item trades.

[beemo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63126191&userid=561369&signature=6Xb4E4HdNLkvDXDwJS8CTQ

Is this fair? I asked on the previous page along with a reply of thanks but it wasn't answered. Thanks to all help I get!

Demand wise it's up to you and your trade partner as it's a personal preferance but rarity wise it's unfair to the zonkey <3

Don't give false advice. The zonkey hasn't been placed on the list yet; it has no set value.

It's not exactly false. It is unfair to the Zonkey rarity wise, it's not going to be placed as a September List pet, that's just common knowledge. I do think people should mention it hasn't been placed, but being an OMGSR UR pet, it will be on the Main List.

[casper.]

Is this fair? Thank you :3

very unfair to the blue rose, their dog is on the advent list :3

I agree, its very unfair to the the blue rose dog as it is a september list where as the timber wolf is an advent list.

[Bok Choy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63126960&userid=561369&signature=ZPZvqOE76R3Y043G0hga9g

It's me again. Just want to know, is this fair? I'm not very well versed with item trades.

[akhela]

this?

i know demand is personal but would you accept this? is it fair? thanks for any help ♥︎

[ace.of.spades]

Fair yes or no?

Bloop

I don't think it is fair personally, because;
As the red rose pps is a main list and although they are offering the ur ice cat, the cheshire has very high demand which may even lead to be worth more than the ur ice cat. The two bunnies don't help the trade more balanced either.

A red rose pps is worth 11 mid advents. The ice cat is worth about just over 34. The bunnies are both mid advents. The cheshire can go for one with popularity. So unfair to the ice cat.

More opinions?

[Alina]

this?

i know demand is personal but would you accept this? is it fair? thanks for any help ♥︎

No, definitely not. What they are asking for is greedy demand.
The pps lion isn't even worth one of the lowest advent list pets, and you have a high and also good demand bat dog from the September list on your side plus all the other stuff.
The chesire alone is overpay rarity wise, especially since it won't ever get rereleased. The chesire alone can also fetch low-mid advent lists, so it alone would be already fair in my opinion.
I mean you can value the lion where you want because like you said, everyone can value the demand of their pets differently but this is just out of any sense.
I'd personally never trade that much for a pet that will get rereleased every year and that is just worth another 2012 vr, and I'd highly suggest you to remove at least the purple batdog

[akhela]

this?

i know demand is personal but would you accept this? is it fair? thanks for any help ♥︎

No, definitely not. What they are asking for is greedy demand.
The pps lion isn't even worth one of the lowest advent list pets, and you have a high and also good demand bat dog from the September list on your side plus all the other stuff.
The chesire alone is overpay rarity wise, especially since it won't ever get rereleased. The chesire alone can also fetch low-mid advent lists, so it alone would be already fair in my opinion.
I mean you can value the lion where you want because like you said, everyone can value the demand of their pets differently but this is just out of any sense.
I'd personally never trade that much for a pet that will get rereleased every year and that is just worth another 2012 vr, and I'd highly suggest you to remove at least the purple batdog

ahh, thanks ♥︎ could i get a second opinion?