The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nowafflecone]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XNHCn0wqBQ
Hello, would this be okay for my bun? Thanks in advance

[waspinator]

how fair is this? (pets for items)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63112274&userid=301187&signature=bokSSRioc-eqkufbw6Z4Iw

or this? c: (pets for pets)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63114784&userid=301187&signature=iKElFYpG8jrSx89xupl0qw

[dvnc]

I have narrowed it down to two bids... Which one should I consider taking?

x

x


Would love some opinions!

[Fwutter]

Hello! I was hoping to get a few opinions on the trades below. I know that they are unfair to the other person rarity wise but I was wondering if I could get some opinions on which one was better.

Offer One
Offer Two

Thank you in advance!

Offer one: EXTREMELY unfair to the yellow toxic! The blue rose and the red rose don't add up to the placement of the toxics. Demand wise the most I've seen the set go for is a low mainlist or a quantity of mid september list pets. Demand wise a toxic can go for about a sorbet and/or a low/mid main list pet. I've also seen a toxic go for a raven dog.

Offer two: MASSIVELY unfair to the person trading you rarity wise. They added a gearback tribal and a quantity of '09 and '10 rares. That probably adds up about 2-3 tiers below the main gap. Demand wise a gearback tribal goes for less than what it's worth depending on who you trade it two.

Personally I would accept the first one but I highly suggest another opinion

[beemo]

I have narrowed it down to two bids... Which one should I consider taking?

x

x


Would love some opinions!

The second one is better. Sure the BMD has some demand, but the second trade has two pretty high mainlists.

Personally, I would wait for a better offer, but if you're set on one of the two, I'd go with the second.

[dvnc]

I have narrowed it down to two bids... Which one should I consider taking?

x

x


Would love some opinions!

The second one is better. Sure the BMD has some demand, but the second trade has two pretty high mainlists.

Personally, I would wait for a better offer, but if you're set on one of the two, I'd go with the second.

Thank you! - Any idea on what the BMD is going for??

[h e l l o]

thoughts on this trade? hows the demand for cakedogs nowadays? it's never been that high, so i dunno if i really want to accept this trade.

[Tylerr Joseph]

Any opinions? I'm not too good with quantity xx

[nowafflecone]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XNHCn0wqBQ

Hello, would this be okay for my bun? Thanks in advance

[beemo]

Any opinions? I'm not too good with quantity xx

Unfair to the top, UR Rat alone is overpay. The Sorbet is definitely easier to trade off, but the rat doesn't have really bad demand.