The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Thunder lineart s]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vu1U7AL4jA
How's this?

[LovelyRita]

is this fair? I really only want a little above 2 nons worth of pets for my dogtag since I want to trade it down but does this add up to a little above 2 nons?

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63102565&userid=853359&signature=0pTwd791kOImvu1U7AL4jA
How's this?

Extremely unfair to the top. That's a high September while your side could only go for roughly a low advent with demand.

[Sickly Substance]

Hmmnnn I don't know what my Spotted Tribal Bun Advent Tier 6 rerelease from last year is worth/if the trade I have 'em in is fair... I kinda think I should add another rare or very rare to the other person's side, maybe?
Fixed the link (my CS theme made me unable to find the "share trade" text, had to use Ctrl+F)

I'd like more than one response, but in PM please. I have social anxiety, m8

[SunRaes]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63075554&userid=837728&signature=tzs8--mrrGSBLjU7F_dJcQ
Sorry! Not sure if these links work, as I have never used these forums before!

[vapejuice]

This is a bid for my Rose PPS auction, is it fair? (Please incorporate demand)

Edit: Fixed link, sorry for breaking it in the first place!

Unfair to the rose pps, the pets you wanted can only get up to a high advent/low september list pet

Thanks! (Here come the questions- more opinions?)
What would need to be added?
How's the demand of all those store pets?
Do the lists on their side have any good or negative demand?

[LovelyRita]

is this fair? I really only want a little above 2 nons worth of pets for my dogtag since I want to trade it down but does this add up to a little above 2 nons?

[HimikoToga]

They said that because it's a rat, it doesn't have as much demand. Is that true? Also, is this fair? I don't think it is, but I want other opinions.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... smPKEy1Xxg

Is this fair? Please take Rarity and Demand into consideration. If it's unfair, what needs to be added/removed and to which side?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Jw4Qu_bdzQ

Is this fair as well? I don't usually do item trades.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RNFM5jAEMw

[dddddonuts]

Hi everyone! Would this trade be fair for the hippocampus store pet?

[Aleigh]

Would this trade be fair to accept? I feel like I would be overpaying. If so, how much would I need to take out for it to be fair?