The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Gordon]

Is this fair for my UR Aussie?

(unfair to the aussie)

Discounting the commons at this high up the list.

Pink Striped (4 mids), Blood PPS (8 mids), 1 2010 VR, a quantity of recent rares, UR Apple (15 mids), Blue Tox, 3 mid advents, a 2nd tier and a Red Rose (5 mids)

And an android at whatever you value him at.

So that's 35 mid advents, 1 2010 vr, recent rares, commons, Blue Tox and a 2nd tier. (and android)

It's 21 mids to get the Blue Tox to next tier. Then another 21 to Purple Tox tier.

So this gets to just under a Purple Tox tier.

Thank you for the help! Can I get some other opinions to make sure?

[Zacharie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63099747&userid=805652&signature=JbNRYb0g3lPGWKbUl7M1Sw

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sXuyvpjYzg

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cSHJHS-AiQ - this one says they can add a spotted tribal too

ok i narrowed it down to three trades thanks to someone who posted (for some reason the post was gone when i tried to quote it ^^;) could someone tell me which of these is fairest demand wise (since i know they're overpay rarity wise, but the raven's demand is huge )

[Eagle's Eye]

Would this have been fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sJbZnnxkqA

Thanks in advance ♡

Your side is worth roughly 9/10 2009 rares. Value wise that's overpay, but from what I heard, that advent dog has quite good demand.

[pillowa]

Would you accept this? D:
Thanks so much in advance! <3

[Vampcifer]

Would this have been fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sJbZnnxkqA

Thanks in advance ♡

Your side is worth roughly 9/10 2009 rares. Value wise that's overpay, but from what I heard, that advent dog has quite good demand.

Okay thank you ♡

[Horror]

Questions on warrior cats:
What are they worth?

Warrior cats are worth 1-2 09' rares including the uncommon ones, But with their demand they go for overpay,

Please don't give false advice.
The uncommon warriors are only worth an early '10 uncommon.
Some rare warriors are worth an early '10 rare and some are worth a mid late 09. The VRs are worth a mid late 09 VR/2 09 rares.
Not everyone overpay for warriors as not everyone likes them, it's personal preference.

[YESMAN]

Would you accept this? D:
Thanks so much in advance! <3

NO WAY! The zebra is so close on the mainlist that it is not even close to fair!

[Kabuski]

-Items-
1
2
3
4
5
Questions on items:
Are either of the trades fair?
If not what do my items add up to

-Warrior Cats-
6

Questions on warrior cats:
What are they worth?

[Topiratti]

Blue toxic = how many mid advents
Line tribal = how many mid advents

Thanks to anyone who answers

[Silverwolf97]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EKj69dqo7g

They would like me to edit to make it fair, I just wanted some opinions before doing so