The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[eboy]

Is this fair?

Hello!
they are actually overpaying since the foal is UR and is worth about 2 nons, UR pets are worth quite a bit
their demand is decent
personally, i probably not accept it because the pets you are offering has great demand but if you want to good luck

[_+TuxedoCat+_]

This doesn't look fair to me... Opinions?

[derogatory]

Could I get some help with this?

I get confused really easily with rares ;;

[Artiermis]

is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... p-WeoWhQlg
thank you in advance! ;v;

[Llamawings]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uYR-tKzlMg

is this fair? thanks in advance ^^

[Bloodpaw/Sangre]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ec_tKUb4uw

Is this quantity for my Cake Dog fair? ^_^

[Fwutter]

is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... p-WeoWhQlg
thank you in advance! ;v;

MASSIVELY unfair to your UR b-wolf, the pets they offered could only get you to a low sept list

[acatalepsy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63093813&userid=819500&signature=gYC_bkNz_0JCuYR-tKzlMg

Is this Fair? Thanks in advance

Cloud really use some help with this trade thank you very much ^^

xxxxx□Unfair to the tinsel horse, which is worth 5-6 2009 rares. The store pets add to about four 2009 rares (valuing the 2012 at 1 2009 rare + 1 2010 rare and each 2015 at an early-mid 2010 rare)

2014 rare for a 2010 uncommon?

xxxxx□Depends on the specific pets, but in general, most opinions I have seen would not trade a 2014 rare for a 2010 UC. A general consensus seems to be that a 2014 rare would equal about a 2012 UC (one rarity lower, two years higher is a common guideline)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63088014&userid=838115&signature=U_N5FNqWurSKdUCvr1agNg
Hello! I could use some big help, is this fair to me and them? I'm contemplating this a lot and don't know for sure. I really need help with this, I'm not the best with trading list wise.

xxxxx□Depends on where you value the Zodiac. The Spotted Tribal Bun is one tier below the Pink Cookie. If you value the Zodiac at a 2010 rare, then the trade is fair, as the 2010-2011 pets (including Zodiac) add to about one 2009 rare, enough for the gap. If you value the Zodiac at a 2009 rare or above, then the Zodiac alone would be enough for the gap, and thus the Spotted Tribal Bun + Zodiac alone would be fair for the Pink Cookie. The 2014-2017 pets don't make a big difference in the trade value

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63097066&userid=859196&signature=I2Zv4JjVZmlRPdo8Hid_hQ

Fair?

xxxxx□Unfair to the Dice PPS, which is worth 7-8 2009 rares. The rats add up to four 2009 rares at most

This doesn't look fair to me... Opinions?

xxxxx□I would say it's up to how you value the dog (i believe that that is the one that can fetch more than its date/rarity worth?). Valuing it at a regular 2009 VR, and valuing the store pets each as a late 2010 rare, the trade would be about fair, but if you value the dog as more than a mid-2009 VR, then yes, the trade is unfair

Could I get some help with this?

I get confused really easily with rares ;;

xxxxx□The spider is from Halloween of 2009, so by date/rarity it and the Evil GUPPS are fair swaps!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63093813&userid=819500&signature=gYC_bkNz_0JCuYR-tKzlMg

is this fair? thanks in advance ^^

xxxxx□Very unfair to the UR BW. They're not offering more than a low September List value, and the UR BW is worth much more than that

[Miss Biscuit~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GGV1ozYaPw
How fair is this?

[bilodope;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63098920&userid=799713&signature=huF13lIfy6gAP5YPDirZxw
thanks in advance, need to know demand wise!