The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Joof]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63088243&userid=784960&signature=kOex0xToHFm3gbfw4rWM1g

How was this for my pocky?

Rarity wise, no one can tell for sure as the item guide is outdated, however the Pocky would most likely not be valued at a September list.
Demand wise it's unfair for the other person, in my opinion, as the pocky item has only been going for a few 09 rares or a mid advent list in auction.

They overpaid quite a bit in my opinion. From what i have seen, pocky tends to go for a mid advent at most. And honestly, i don't think it's that rare, there are a lot of trades (and thus pocky) around at the moment. It's just high in demand right now. The item guide might be a bit outdated, but not that much (:

Two Sunjewel = UR Tiger? Demand wise c; thanks

I'd say no. While the list already considers demand (which makes ur tiger still equal to sunjewel), i have seen tiger dogs fetch like 7-8 nons, depending on the pets involved. Two sunjewels would be 10 nons which is just a lot of demand re-applied (:

[Kitty Cheshire]

Thank you but I was offer the two sunjewels c; I forgot to mention, so would it be a good idea to take it?

[PoppyTina]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63088243&userid=784960&signature=kOex0xToHFm3gbfw4rWM1g

How was this for my pocky?

Rarity wise, no one can tell for sure as the item guide is outdated, however the Pocky would most likely not be valued at a September list.
Demand wise it's unfair for the other person, in my opinion, as the pocky item has only been going for a few 09 rares or a mid advent list in auction.

They overpaid quite a bit in my opinion. From what i have seen, pocky tends to go for a mid advent at most. And honestly, i don't think it's that rare, there are a lot of trades (and thus pocky) around at the moment. It's just high in demand right now. The item guide might be a bit outdated, but not that much (:

Thank you both for your help and advice. I appreciate it very much!

[Shadow2204]

Blue balloon = WWA?
Which am i better off with?

It's a fair swap ^^
I would say you're better off with the balloon dog.

Thank you! Would like to get some more opinions please c:

[Alina]

Blue balloon = WWA?
Which am i better off with?

It's a fair swap ^^
I would say you're better off with the balloon dog.

Thank you! Would like to get some more opinions please c:

Agreed, most people prefer the balloon dogs

[NineTail]

Please help me with this! Thanks!
ClickMeh
One more
another trade

[Shisien]

xXx is this overpay?

[Ranger of the North]

How does it look now?


Is this fair?


And how's this? Apparently it's unfair to the item?


Thanks for any and all help! <3

1 is still unfair to the sorbet
As the top added no main lists

2 is ridiculously unfair to you
Still no main lists

3 is indeed unfair to the item as it's worth 6 c $

Thank you so much! <3 So if they add a main list it will be fair, yes?

Awesome, thank you! >^.^<

Tysm! <3

It actually is going to depend on the main list itself :^)

Oki doke. Is there a thread or anything with a list of the mains, so I can have a look at 'em? c: #BadAtCSInGeneral *facepalm* (tysm for all the help, btw c: )


Alsoo, could I please get one more opinion on trade three, just to be sure? c:


Thanks all for the help! <3

[Croissee]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63088103&userid=859819&signature=2puGrd-l9GHl_zJvYjCtnw
Is this fair?

[NineTail]

Please help me with this! Thanks!
ClickMeh
One more
another trade