The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Aralas]

Could anyone help me with this trade? How can it be made fair? What needs to be added / removed? What's the difference in value between the two sides? Thank you for any help!

That's very unfair to the bottom. Although the items are rare and retired, I still don't think they're worth the flower pot. I'm not entirely sure about the difference, but they'd need to add a high main list (under the gap) at the very least.

[Jiloon]

are pocky boxes worth that much?

Don't know about the bid, but the Pocky is worth a late 08 rare (listed here), so a Main list pet for it wouldn't be fair; you are overpaying. I believe the most it will go for is a mid advent, but you're best getting other opinions on that, and just to check my response too C:

The Item Guide is a tad out of date, as a few people have pointed out on the discussion over there, but you're mostly correct. The Pocky is worth an '08 R-VR, but I always trade mine off for more. Twice, mine have gone for low Septembers, and recently I traded one off for a Red-X dog. That was a special outlier though, and I don't think I'll see a trade like that again cx I'd say that the Pocky item usually goes for a mid-high Advent, depending on the demand. I've been offered a Grinner for mine many times, but because of the low demand, I didn't accept those. I'd just say a mid-high Advent c:

[elio.]

How does this trade work?
Thank you in advance, all opinions help!

[Loki~Neith]

Was this a good trade? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... PRlhfCf6vA

[Kabuski]

Is this bid + add on unfair to them?

Thank you guys for the help on the pocky box! It's very appreciated ^^

[Girlyj]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mQpMW6ci8A

Is that trade fair? Demand wise that is.

[Yeens]

fair?

[hummxs]

Is this fair? I believe the pink heart is a tier 7 advent.

boop

[pigeon -]

Is this fair? I believe the pink heart is a tier 7 advent.

boop

it would be overpay their side as the cream advent and pink heart would be a fair swap c:

[Smaug The Dragon]

How many sorbs. add up to each side in this trade?
If mines under the amount of sorbs. needed for the nons, How many nons will need to be taken away?
Also, is a UR peach worth a non+, or no?

The Spotted tribal is worth around 1,5 sorbets, the peach hasn't been going for nons lately. No one can say you what it's worth as it hasn't been placed yet but lately it often went for 1-1,5 sorbets, so the spottet tribal + peach are worth around a non together.

The other pets on your side are worth less than a sorbet together so you would have to remove three nons on their side and the Nonballoon and the non-list stuff on your side.
Or you have to remove two nons on their side and add 2 sorbets + around a rose pps on your side to make it fair for two nons.

Alright! Thanks! ^-^
What non would be recommended to have? The non coon, the non tag, the non jewl, or the non moon swirl?