The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Kitkat2716]

Thank you kody. for your help!
thank you also Zetirian, i really appreciate that answer

[ร ק ๏ ๏ Շ]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62881763&userid=710761&signature=YpREUPtVnEkHmGSbkaS3fQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MEhcLVJQtA

Two new trades! ^^
Is it fair through?

Trade 1: It is a fair tier swap but the red rose has good demand, and foes for overpay, whereas the pink patched September is hard to trade off

2. This is a nice overpay, the dark leopard alone is at the top of the September list, and is quite overpay alone. The rest of the pets are also overpay

Thank you! Second opnions?

[Alina]

Spotted Tribal + ? = Growing white July

Red toxic + grinner + ? = Spotted Tribal

What would fill the gap?

[Donna the Fox]

Is this fair? Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YuIMnmg_Vg

[lordramen]

What should be done to make this fair rarity and demand wise? :3

I also just got this(Is it fair demand wise? :3)

And this?

Please help!

[KatSkan]

Hi guys, is this trade fair? Thanks to anyone who can help! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5ACdDGG_OQ

[LostInTheEcho]

Is this trade fair? Thank you
Edit: This?
And this one? [2]

Which of these three is the fairest?

The third trade by far is the most fair trade, the other two don't even include a list pet. Some of the items in the trade are quite old also. In C$ the flowers is worth around 1015C$ but like some of the Urs has bad demand so it usually goes for a sorbet worth which is around 765 C$ altogether their side would add up to approximately 550C$. So is unfair to you, but if they added 200 more C$ it would be perfectly fair:)

Thank you
May I have a second opinion?

[waspinator]

how does this look? there's too many pets for me to understand easily,,
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62887699&userid=301187&signature=URZq_vtwWG12uDf1VNcVcw

[rainfall.]

i desperately need a reply for this before i go to school, please help! is it fair? would you accept it? any help is greatly appreciated, thank you!! c:

[ThunderCedar]

i desperately need a reply for this before i go to school, please help! is it fair? would you accept it? any help is greatly appreciated, thank you!! c:

Extremely unfair to them
That dog is worth 2 nons.


And yes I would