The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Vampcifer]

Is this fair? If not what do they add?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Gjh6hpCzrA

Is this fair? I dont want to keep them waiting

[Cell ii]

Blue ice rat(near the top of September list) for peppermint bun(Advent tier 3)? Blue ice rat seems like a hell of a lot overpay.

[wonderlandfox]

Would this be fair?
boop
Demand wise with the longtail?
What should be added/removed?

{Second opinion needed}

[.crossfire.]

is this fair? I was told the item can equal a 2011 uncommon or a 2015-2014 rare?

X

A 2011 uncommon is worth a 2013 rare actually c:

ah ok. But, is this fair?

[luc]

Should I accept this offer?

It's pretty big overpay on their side. Your pet is worth a late '10 rare and they're offering a bit more than twice the value. I usually don't see a single recent store pet going for more than this

Thank you!

is this the best i can get for my pocky at auction?

[Ranger of the North]

1

Taking the fact that C$ is pretty valuable to me (I don't have the money to buy it, so everything 'store' is off-limits otherwise :p) into account, is this fair? c:

For trade 1, sorbets are worth a dark leopard (top tier september) and a top tier mid august. The red dragon is only a bottom tier september. Even if you value the C$ more highly than usual, at say, a mid/low september, it would still be unfair to you. The store dragons do not make up much of that gap, especially since they just left the store. Note that this isn't taking into account the demand, so if you're wondering about that then definitely get more opinions.

Okay, thank you so much! <3
Could I please get a second opinion? c:

2

Kia ora!
Is this fair?
Thanks so, so much for any help! <3

Opinions? c: C$ is more valuable to me than usual, btw; I can't buy it, so everything 'store' is basically off-limits otherwise c:

[contra.]

I don't have a link but is the laptop item worth a 2013 rare? If not what is it worth?

[mothstelid]

I don't have a link but is the laptop item worth a 2013 rare? If not what is it worth?

The laptop item is worth an early 09 rare, I think. Get another opinion, too :)

[_BlackWidow_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62889254&userid=754849&signature=2QK17nF2358GOOw26cbiGA

Opinions?

[Zetirian]

1

Taking the fact that C$ is pretty valuable to me (I don't have the money to buy it, so everything 'store' is off-limits otherwise :p) into account, is this fair? c:

For trade 1, sorbets are worth a dark leopard (top tier september) and a top tier mid august. The red dragon is only a bottom tier september. Even if you value the C$ more highly than usual, at say, a mid/low september, it would still be unfair to you. The store dragons do not make up much of that gap, especially since they just left the store. Note that this isn't taking into account the demand, so if you're wondering about that then definitely get more opinions.

Okay, thank you so much! <3
Could I please get a second opinion? c:

2

Kia ora!
Is this fair?
Thanks so, so much for any help! :D <3

Opinions? c: C$ is more valuable to me than usual, btw; I can't buy it, so everything 'store' is basically off-limits otherwise c:

Both of those are drastically unfair to you.

The sorbet is worth 84 mid advents and a red dragon is worth 2 mid advents. With the CS included you would still need anywhere around 40 or so red dragons for it to be fair.

The other trade is about the same worth in that aspect. The Rare's and stuff are worth 3-4 mid advent lists depending how you value them and basically a long way off the worth of a sorbet, CS included.