The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Cell ii]

Blue ice rat(near the top of September list) for peppermint bun(Advent tier 3)? Blue ice rat seems like a hell of a lot overpay.

[Vampcifer]

Is this fair? If not what do they add?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Gjh6hpCzrA

[Fizzlebee]

Would this be fair for my raven dog in terms of demand? I'm really very iffy on trading it off. I realize this is probably overpay on their side but as I took a 1.5 year semi-hiatus I'd like to get some opinions because I'm a little rusty.

I feel you, came back from a long hiatus myself a few months ago. The raven dog has a lot of demand, so you can get well beyond what it's actually worth on the rares list (high advent). With demand, the raven dog does fetch more than what's being offered in your trade. Most importantly, follow your gut if you're feeling iffy. c:

[lextopia]

Opinions on this trade? x & this one x
Thank youu

[Polyphia]

Would this be fair for my raven dog in terms of demand? I'm really very iffy on trading it off. I realize this is probably overpay on their side but as I took a 1.5 year semi-hiatus I'd like to get some opinions because I'm a little rusty.

I feel you, came back from a long hiatus myself a few months ago. The raven dog has a lot of demand, so you can get well beyond what it's actually worth on the rares list (high advent). With demand, the raven dog does fetch more than what's being offered in your trade. Most importantly, follow your gut if you're feeling iffy. c:

Oh I see, thank you for your help ^^

[.crossfire.]

@fizzlebee sorry that was a typo}
@anyone,
Can you get a nick dog with a beta fish if the dog was released in August 2009, and the beta in September?

[Rain;;]

does this have good demand/fair trade??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... baEOxykF8g

[Cell ii]

@fizzlebee sorry that was a typo}
@anyone,
Can you get a nick dog with a beta fish if the dog was released in August 2009, and the beta in September?

Yes, 3 month rule.

[wonderlandfox]

Would this be fair?
boop
Demand wise with the longtail?
What should be added/removed?

{Second opinion needed}

[.crossfire.]

@fizzlebee sorry that was a typo}
@anyone,
Can you get a nick dog with a beta fish if the dog was released in August 2009, and the beta in September?

Yes, 3 month rule.

ok, thanks!