The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[SteampunkAngel]

Sorry im adding more but just how much is this one?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0fZmGsfcRg

Been asking for 7 pages now ;-;

On the second trade it's more complicated because zodiacs go for more than their worth. I personally value each at an 09 rare so will work it out that way.

Quantity side: UR Dog, Skeleton PPS (12 mids), Cake Dog (6mids), 4 mids, a first tier, a third tier, zodiac at an 09 rare, 5 2014 store pets at an early 2010 rare each.

So you have the UR Dog plus 22 mids, 1st tier, 3rd tier and rares that would get you another advent value ish.

Starting at the UR Dog, it's 11 mids to UR Butterbun tier, 8mids + 4th tier to sorbet tier, then 10 mids to blue tox tier. It's a balloon dog to get to CEG (21 mids).

So you would get to about maybe above a sorbet, below a blue tox tier?

Main list and quantity replies tend to be slow since a lot of people struggle with the math, I do also, it's brain melting...but gives a rough idea hopefully. It also takes all day to do this x'D

Again shoot me if I'm wrong, it's so much it's easy to miss stuff

[Kazin]

Keep getting trades for my Tier 1 Basilisk, and I was wondering if either of these two were fair for him, factoring in demand?

Trade 1 - Malk PPS + bun

Trade 2 - advent bun

and they just keep coming and I have no idea if they're really fair xD trade 3 - advent bun
Any help, even on just one of these, is greatly appreciated!

Sorry for bulky post, PMs are welcome too ^^

[Vampcifer]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NxHe2Y1atQ

Is this fair? Personally I don't think it is but I would like to see if I'm right or wrong. Thank you ♡

[Flicka]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -w1cxIBMZg
is this better for my nick horse?
^ This horse is a re-release of '09

I've had three different oppinions on it. two people said it was unfair to me and one said it was unfair to them. I really need to know what it is.

[.crossfire.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62823808&userid=735092&signature=WNU83Kr51-QZNxHe2Y1atQ

Is this fair? Personally I don't think it is but I would like to see if I'm right or wrong. Thank you ♡

In order for it to be fair, they need to add at least a 2012 uncommon, or 2.. or they could just add two 2012 commons. On the 2015-2016 part they are over paying just a tad. And they could add a 2014 common if you want it rarity for rarity, or just the fairness.. but thats what I would do. Get a second opinion though :3

[Happy~Face]

Should I take this? c: I'm just really attached to my UR Tiger... and it will be extremely hard for me to get another one DX
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kfttefSWzg

[Halsie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g6h5yLdLDg

Is this fair?

[blossoms,7]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VmAAK4yIgA


Should I accept this?

What can I get with the 143 dollars ?

[Alee13]

Would this be a good trade? I'm not too sure how much the animal eggs are worth. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62823583&userid=351993&signature=O0Vc13iPa_03Q_5uXv01-Q

[LovelyRita]

is this fair? would I be better off just keeping my store pets or taking the 08 dog?