The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[smairy]

thank you guys ^^

how fair is this one? does the skull rat have bad demand

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GjmRTNJc4Q
thank you

Unfair to them;
Rats in general have bad demand, but they are overpaying a lot rarity wise, as the skull rat is on the September List. I only see one list pet on your side, which is a low advent.

[Halsie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eoz7lb7qgw

I know this is a pretty fair trade(right?) but I'm just wondering how in demand the German Shepherd is. Thanks!

[SteampunkAngel]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rjYbxLxMjQ

How unfair is this? I dont want a fair trade i just want an acceptable amouut round about 70% or 80% of the value

Sorry im adding more but just how much is this one?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0fZmGsfcRg

Been asking for 7 pages now ;-;

I avoid high main list trades, especially quantity ones but here goes on the first one:

Quantity side: 300C$ is about a grey dragon tier (8 mids), 2 mids, blue balloon, red x (7 mids), 1st tier, 2nd tier.

Starting from the Blue Balloon on the list, it's 3 mids to next tier, 5 and a 2nd tier to line tribal tier, 5 to nonballoon and 7 to green tox tier.

So that's a blue balloon, 8, a 2nd tier, 12 to get to green tox tier so far.

You have the blue balloon, 8 in the C$, the 2nd tier and 9 in the red x and 7th tiers. Then only a first tier left so doesn't quite get you to a green toxic tier.

Someone beat me up if it's overly wrong xP

[smairy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62820516&userid=735532&signature=hcAl9CCr3WiP3Y4zGW2YJg
I know they're probably overpaying, but I don't really like rats and I don't know if I would get anything decent for the rat

They are overpaying by a lot!
Rats are usually very hard to trade away, so I can see where your partner is going with this.
Its up to you really; If you prefer the rarity, then go for it.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62792236&userid=656194&signature=8uDXyZOATh0oeoz7lb7qgw

I know this is a pretty fair trade(right?) but I'm just wondering how in demand the German Shepherd is. Thanks!

Yes, this is completely fair.
German Shepherds demand are usually pretty good from what I've seen. It's up to you if you prefer the German shepherd or not as demand is often opinion based, but personally, I wouldn't take it.

[Dumbdolphin]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62823524&userid=862451&signature=7nR-KlxKioxI2N3J5fqZ4A

Opinions?

[grizzegrijn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rr3V0iDa1Q

is this fair?

[Kazin]

Keep getting trades for my Tier 1 Basilisk, and I was wondering if either of these two were fair for him, factoring in demand?

Trade 1 - Malk PPS + bun

Trade 2 - advent bun

and they just keep coming and I have no idea if they're really fair xD trade 3 - advent bun
Any help, even on just one of these, is greatly appreciated!

Sorry for bulky post, PMs are welcome too ^^

[smairy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62823524&userid=862451&signature=7nR-KlxKioxI2N3J5fqZ4A

Opinions?

I think its a little unfair to you;
I just based it off the three month rule since both of them are store pets.

[luc]

Thinking of auto-ing on this auction bid. Should I? I quite like it.

[smairy]

Thinking of auto-ing on this auction bid. Should I? I quite like it.

They are overpaying;
There is a good amount of high demand pets in there (Mainly the uncommons though).
It's up to you, really.