The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[elio.]

is this fair? im terrible with lists xc

thank you in advance!!

[Kabuski]

Is this fair? What are my items worth?

[Fwutter]

is this fair? im terrible with lists xc

thank you in advance!!

According to the rares list guide, they are overpaying by a ton. The green toxic is way farther down on the main list than the OMGSR nick horse. Also the red pps dog isnt even on the mainlist, it's on the advent list. All though it is very high on the advent list, it's no where near the worth of a OMGSR horse. The VR tess horse is high on the september list, not on the mainlist either. Also, the shima long tail isn't even a list pet period, it just has drastically high demand. So the person trading you the OMGSR nick horse is over trading tremendously

I would ask for another opinion, but i did do research while responding to this so i may be right c:

[Jiloon]

Hello!

I know they're overpaying rarity wise, but how does this look with demand? I'm looking to keep trading up, and I'm not so sure I can do that with this pet, plus I posted I had a Red Android for trade, and instantly got two or three T7 offers. Is it going for more than that due to demand? Thanks for any advice c:

Clicky

[Oshawott8888]

is this fair ^^?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UhNj1gKtUQ
what do marionettes go for on average ^^?
is this trade better ^^?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u1tVel7XwA

edit or would this be better ^^?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... PL2qEfIC9g
edit
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kbWl8CeM0g

also would a ur foal+a blue toxic be fair for a raven dog demand wise?
or what would be fair ^^?
would a mint tess horse be better?
sorry for the bulk of links, if i dont put em all at once then i lose track of em ^^'

[LovelyRita]

is this fair? I know the 08 halo is worth a mid September list pet but I'm unsure if these pets add up to it

[bee ♥]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... PgFAXsqZFw

Would this be fair?

thanks for the help!

[SpyroMello]

is this fair? I know the 08 halo is worth a mid September list pet but I'm unsure if these pets add up to it

It depends on if you like bunnies. Many people don't like bunnies (I do) but these pets do add up roughly to a mid september. I feel that because the tier 7 is the least liked pps that it also affects whether it's fair or not. I still think it's roughly fair but get another opinion.

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=62506384&userid=818839&signature=1GpbvvXlIU0fPgFAXsqZFw

Would this be fair?

thanks for the help!

They are overtading by a lot. All though tokens have high demand during the event, they are useless once it's over. I think about 10 uncommons would have been enough. The nick horse makes this an extreme overpay.

[Eagle's Eye]

How's this? I don't know all of the item values