The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[juyeo]

Hi! So, I'm currently holding an auction for both Hollyleaf and Brightheart, so I was wondering which bid was the best?
Bid for Brightheart + Bid for Hollyleaf
or
Bid for Both
or
Bid for Both
Any help is appreciated, and if I could get several opinions that would be great!

[Luncasi]

1 and 2.

Okay, those should be the correct ones, sorry for messing up so much.

[Rinsea]

Hi! So, I'm currently holding an auction for both Hollyleaf and Brightheart, so I was wondering which bid was the best?
Bid for Brightheart + Bid for Hollyleaf
or
Bid for Both
or
Bid for Both
Any help is appreciated, and if I could get several opinions that would be great!

I would pick the first bid for both because most of these bid one 2009 rare for each cat but this one bid a 2009 rare and a malk elemental cat (high demand)

Get a second opinion to be sure

[Honorchior]

Help. I am very bad with list trades! What would need to be added for it to be fair! Tahnk s for any help! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a2Mc5qRkFg

Gifting helpful answers!

[Kabuski]

Is this fair?

[Pompiix]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I2d50ZzdMw

personally i dont think this trade is fair, 2 2015 rares for 2017 unknowen rarity. i dont think so. but lets see what other people think

this is the message she/he sent along with the trade.

Cymothoa said:
I'll do this, an uncommon is worth a 2 year younger rare, (a 2010 uncommon= a 2012 rare and so on) please feel free to check with the "is it fair thread"

[hummxs]

Is this fair?

Yes, I believe it is fair. The 2012 store pet was bought with 20 C$, and with every year that passes raises its value by a little bit. Adding a little more than 1 C$ per year, because it's 2017, I believe that is a correct value.

[Takk]

Help. I am very bad with list trades! What would need to be added for it to be fair! Tahnk s for any help! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a2Mc5qRkFg

Gifting helpful answers!

Their side is worth around 5 mid advents while the dark leopard is worth 9
They're about a scarf pps short, demand is between partners if you/they have any demand concerns

[C_E_Lover]

I recently received this trade, is this fair? I'm usually good with determining but with rares, rereleases and dates I am not so good. The draftie is from Valentine's 2010 clicky
Thanks for any and all advice!

[employer]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... N4S45HlJ1A
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8tVqkdZz7Q
I'm not sure with these two, help please?