The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[LostForever]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61663359&userid=855492&signature=OwYxSWVXeIkzhwaBmZUJLA

Is this fair? I really need help on this one!

Its overpay on the bottom, the 2017 store pet is worth and early 11 rare If you follow how past storepets have been valued

[its_loki]

hello!
i'd very much like some opinions on this trade, please! i'm quite conflicted, so i'd very much appreciate some help (:
thank you all in advance!

edit:
i'd gotten another offer after posting here, so i'd like some opinions on this one, too, please!
thank you!

[Joof]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61663359&userid=855492&signature=OwYxSWVXeIkzhwaBmZUJLA

Is this fair? I really need help on this one!

Its overpay on the bottom, the 2017 store pet is worth and early 11 rare If you follow how past storepets have been valued

That's not right. A recent (still in store) store pet is worth a late '10 rare not early '11. Therefore it seems about fair as the offered pet is a mid '10 rare and the store pets just left the store (:

[~Misty]

Is this fair? If not, how much are the Sunback Plushies worth each?
Thanks!

[piggie]

I have no clue whether this trade is fair or not. Any help would be appreciated! Thank you so much c:

[Kitty Cheshire]

Is this fair? If not, how much are the Sunback Plushies worth each?
Thanks!

They are worth an 09 rare each but tend to go for overpay. So technically it's unfair to them because they are offering, correct me if I am wrong, it could be a 10 very rare(yup 09) but I think it's an 09 very rare, a 2012 uncommon and early plushies.

[~Misty]

Is this fair? If not, how much are the Sunback Plushies worth each?
Thanks!

They are worth an 09 rare each but tend to go for overpay. So technically it's unfair to them because they are offering, correct me if I am wrong, it could be a 10 very rare but I think it's an 09 very rare, a 2012 uncommon and early plushies.

Well add demand to the factors and they're worth a lot more am I correct? I got rid of my others for lists.

[Kitty Cheshire]

Is this fair? If not, how much are the Sunback Plushies worth each?
Thanks!

They are worth an 09 rare each but tend to go for overpay. So technically it's unfair to them because they are offering, correct me if I am wrong, it could be a 10 very rare but I think it's an 09 very rare, a 2012 uncommon and early plushies.

Well add demand to the factors and they're worth a lot more am I correct? I got rid of my others for lists.

I took a look at the how much is this item worth, and yes the sunback goes for an 09 rare or very rare, forgot to mention very rare but with demand I have seen the suns go for low list pets but I don't see that often. I normally see them go for around 3 09 rares.

[pigeon -]

I have no clue whether this trade is fair or not. Any help would be appreciated! Thank you so much c:

okay so you'll need a second opinion as well but i believe this would be unfair to the non,
they're offering an above the gap main list, whereas your side may have a lot of quantity
but i can only see around 4 list pets that are advent/sept [ correct me if i'm wrong ] and
then a lot of rares, stores etc ~ those stores, rares etc don't fill the gap between the non
and the advent lists your side even if the rares have good demand [ like warrior cats ] c:

[Kitty Cheshire]

Fair? I'm a bit iffy when it comes to store pets demand and rarity.