last known ftt! Be sure to head to the new thread!

[Eagle's Eye]

Is this fair?

Originally they offered a 2013 Halloween rare and a 2011 uncommon for all three of my tigers (click here for original offer). If it's not fair, what should be added/taken away?

All together your pets are worth an 09 rare + '10 rare. So they would be over paying now. Just the 09 dog and the store unicorn would be fair.

The '09 dog would be fair for two of your tigers but the unicorn would be slightly overpay for one of the tigers as store pet values rise with their age.

[SmokeyKitty]

Is this fair?

Originally they offered a 2013 Halloween rare and a 2011 uncommon for all three of my tigers (click here for original offer). If it's not fair, what should be added/taken away?

All together your pets are worth an 09 rare + '10 rare. So they would be over paying now. Just the 09 dog and the store unicorn would be fair.

The '09 dog would be fair for two of your tigers but the unicorn would be slightly overpay for one of the tigers as store pet values rise with their age.

Thank you! ^_^ I figured it was overpay but I just wanted more opinions before accepting anything.

[acatalepsy]

is this fair? If not, what could they/I add??

Hey x
They are over paying.
Why?

Because;
The rat::
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/archive/ ... tember/Rat

The elf dress can also go for an 09 rare trust me on that. Lol. People love those items. I still can't get anyone to trade me one.

Thank you! Could I get s second opinion?

xxxxx□The Elven set as a whole is worth around an early-ish '10 rare or a bit more but I'm not sure how much each individual item is worth. The rat is a rare from '09, but it also has much less demand compared to the tiger. I think it's all on how you'd want to take it. Sure, the rat side by rarity is worth more, but there won't be much of a use in trading the rat off again afterwards

Is this fair?

Originally they offered a 2013 Halloween rare and a 2011 uncommon for all three of my tigers (click here for original offer). If it's not fair, what should be added/taken away?

xxxxx□As for the second trade, each of those store pets is worth a late 2010 rare, so they'd have to add about two late 2010 rares and a 2011 rare or so

[Oshawott8888]

are these 2 trades fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZDnk1-XtYA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Q5_ukOhjEA

[Buster2918]

Anyone have an idea on how I can make this trade fair? It's for a bid, thank you in advance for any help!

[ThunderCedar]

Anyone have an idea on how I can make this trade fair? It's for a bid, thank you in advance for any help!

That's very unfair to the Moonswirl. Your side doesn't come close to it at all. You need to add over a dogtag. Like a dogtag and a ur holly or something like that

[Buster2918]

Anyone have an idea on how I can make this trade fair? It's for a bid, thank you in advance for any help!

That's very unfair to the Moonswirl. Your side doesn't come close to it at all. You need to add over a dogtag. Like a dogtag and a ur holly or something like that

I'm aware it isn't fair, that's why I'm asking how I can make it fair, thanks for answering though. They are looking for WL store pets and they seem to like the quantity of store pets, but of course it's not the best bid. Some more opinions/advice please?

[blossoms,7]

are these 2 trades fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZDnk1-XtYA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Q5_ukOhjEA

All I know is the second one, is really unfair to them, 1 of those 09 very rares would be fair, the nick sun pup doesn't have any demand, it goes for it's regular value,

[ThunderCedar]

Anyone have an idea on how I can make this trade fair? It's for a bid, thank you in advance for any help!

That's very unfair to the Moonswirl. Your side doesn't come close to it at all. You need to add over a dogtag. Like a dogtag and a ur holly or something like that

I'm aware it isn't fair, that's why I'm asking how I can make it fair, thanks for answering though. They are looking for WL store pets and they seem to like the quantity of store pets, but of course it's not the best bid. Some more opinions/advice please?

Maybe adding an orange cerberus would do it for them then even though it'd still be under of course people can hardly say no to a cerb :.

[acatalepsy]

are these 2 trades fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZDnk1-XtYA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Q5_ukOhjEA

All I know is the second one, is really unfair to them, 1 of those 09 very rares would be fair, the nick sun pup doesn't have any demand, it goes for it's regular value,

xxxxx□I can back that up. The first is unfair to the Target Dog, which is one tier higher and I believe has slightly better demand than the Grinners. The other pets snd item, as far as i cam tell, do not make up that gap