The "is this a fair trade?" Thread - info front page!

[Kaname]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59340983&userid=7864

can someone help me, i need this done quick, don't like to let trades rot!

unviewable

did you copy and paste the url and then try, if so then idk how to make it work but i can tell what it is

the problem is that you copy and pasted the actual url, not the [share trade] url. you can tell me what it is though, i'd prefer seeing the actual trade.

[Tylerr Joseph]

is this fair?

[ღNightmareღ]

Fair?

[Sarin]

Is this fair, considering demand for the pets?

Thank you for any help! ^^

[pleasantboy69]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59340763&userid=671881&signature=xxsYmQ3Yk-Yo4q6SMZ6Vtg

is this fair? thank you! c:

this one as well! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59341188&userid=671881&signature=elMyNc4caPB4iXPIuP3mvA

[WolFox]

Is this fair?

And I don't think this one is, but I'd like someone's opinion!

That dog in the second one is a re-release may 2009, it is over pay!

The dog isn't a re-release. It's from 2011. In my opinion, I would accept both trades.
1. Two Uncommon horses and the 09' rare is just fine. They are overpaying a bit..
2. Date-wise unfair to them. I'd accept this too (:

can i get some help?, thanks!

Can't see the trade. Go to 'share trade' and paste that link. (:

How is that PPS pup not a re-release? Because it certainly is from 2009, it was just re-released in 2011 instead of now.

[IkaWxlf]

is this fair?

I wouldn't accept if I were them. Though it may grow to be a VR and is from 2009, that's just way too many pets to expect in exchange.

[Kaname]

is this fair?

i'd say if it's not fair, it's overpaying slightly. whatever sorbet you get that comes out from your litter will be only 2 tiers above the gearback tribal and i think they have adequately closed up that gap with the added list pets + gearback. it depends on you and what you want.

[ღNightmareღ]

is this fair?

I wouldn't accept if I were them. Though it may grow to be a VR and is from 2009, that's just way too many pets to expect in exchange.

Which side is overpay?

[IkaWxlf]

Is this fair, considering demand for the pets?

Thank you for any help! ^^

I wouldn't accept that, if I were you. I understand it's a VR, but those holly leaf dogs are extremely rare.