The "is this a fair trade?" Thread - info front page!

[xycaetc]

Can anyone tell me if this is fair?
Clicky
Thanks so much!

Unfair to you.

I agree because of the horses bad demand, but please explain why it's not fair/fair

[Joof]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59179402&userid=826894&signature=vn2Fro9sfavknaVjTGE96Q

Am I underpaying for the Zodiac, or is this fine? Feel free to PM me.

Actually it was unfair to you. Zodiacs go for a mid to ealry 09 rare, your side is worth almost 3 09 rares. The store pets have good demand aswell and would have been about fair for the zodiac (:

Can anyone tell me if this is fair?
Clicky
Thanks so much!

Unfair to you.

I agree because of the horses bad demand, but please explain why it's not fair/fair

Actually it's unfair because the lion is an advent list pet and worth a handful of 09 rares. Not because the draft and pony have bad demand (:

[kapetrovaa]

Can anyone tell me if this is fair?
Clicky
Thanks so much!

Unfair to you.

please follow the rules of the thread, and give a reason to why it's unfair.

☆ the tinsel lion is on the advent list; worth around 5 2009 rares, they aren't even offering the equivalent of two.
highly unfair to you (:

[Darkanra]

Can anyone tell me if this is fair?
Clicky
Thanks so much!

Unfair to you.

please follow the rules of the thread, and give a reason to why it's unfair.

☆ the tinsel lion is on the advent list; worth around 5 2009 rares, they aren't even offering the equivalent of two.
highly unfair to you (:

Thanks very much. ^^

[Darkanra]

How about this?

[Sabrientjuh]

I got this trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59179872&userid=833063&signature=iiezRtRRFlJDjrfc0U4VsQ

I never had an event before so I have no idea if this is fear, can someone help me please

[grimwalker]

Blue Balloon + ?? = Raven Dog??

[kapetrovaa]

How about this?

looks around fair, possibly slightly unfair to them.
the item is worth an 09 rare, the very rare rat is originally from 08/09 (not sure which one haha) and the pony is worth an 09 rare. the music store dog is worth a 2010 rare, so along with the 2010 rat it makes another 09 rare.

I advise keeping demand in mind though. People would rather trade for your lion more than they would for the rats, but you could argue either way (:

[Silverstar]

Blue Balloon + ?? = Raven Dog??

If you value the raven at a sorbet, the balloon side needs to add a red toxic.

How about this?

The tinsel lion is worth 5-6 '09 rares, their side adds up to 4 and a half, so they need to add at least another '10 rare.

How about this?

looks around fair, possibly slightly unfair to them.
the item is worth an 09 rare, the very rare rat is originally from 08/09 (not sure which one haha) and the pony is worth an 09 rare. the music store dog is worth a 2010 rare, so along with the 2010 rat it makes another 09 rare.

I advise keeping demand in mind though. People would rather trade for your lion more than they would for the rats, but you could argue either way (:

The bunny can be bought in store for 6 C$, it's worth a '13 rare and a '08 very rare is valued at two '09 rares + a '10 rare ^^

[Lunszpik]

Do you think this one is okay, considering demand?