The "is this a fair trade?" Thread - info front page!

[swiftblossom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59170831&userid=692551&signature=kFTBvfjAS9x4XavihbqkFg

Am I overpaying?

[Ginneh]

Is this fair?

[tazzazi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59173988&userid=305196&signature=rRS0LCLBdPZ9gBZyvdpPLw
Could anyone help me? I'm not the greatest with trading list things... I feel like I like my rose dog better but I'm not sure? Thanks in advance!

Unfair to the rose dog as it is higher on the September list than the light leopard

xxxxxxxx
Thank you in advance. <3


rarity wise, this is obviously unfair for them.
demand wise, i'd say this was either fair or slightly
unfair for you because i feel that rare lions have
pretty good demand and can fetch quite alot ^-^!


Thank you - another opinion?

Agee don't that rarity wise it is unfair to them as the two advent rares are equal. As for demand wise, I feel that there is fair demand for both lions and the sitting cats depending on finding people who want them, so I wouldn't say there is a huge difference in demand either way, but there will always be people to overpay.
Feel free to get another opinion

[yellow paint]

is this fair?

paint

[blossoms,7]

Woah, I'm not good with quanity trades, is this fair? What needs to be removed/added? Thanks in advance!

[tazzazi]

is this fair?

paint

Rarity wise they are overpaying by a lot, but I am not totally sure about the demand of the dragon and how much it is getting at the moment. But they are definitely overpaying based on rarity

[ImogenEquine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59174405&userid=305196&signature=N2DJaZToKEvwGhWXS4I49g
as soon as I cancelled one trade, I got another! Sorry to be asking for help again so soon!

I already have a pink cake dog, and again, I do really like the Rose dog... Who is this fairer for? I kind of feel like the Rose dog has more demand...

[luckydraw]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Las8t-iMYw
thanks in advance

[blossoms,7]

EDIT:
Another trade

[tazzazi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59174405&userid=305196&signature=N2DJaZToKEvwGhWXS4I49g
as soon as I cancelled one trade, I got another! Sorry to be asking for help again so soon!

I already have a pink cake dog, and again, I do really like the Rose dog... Who is this fairer for? I kind of feel like the Rose dog has more demand...

Rarity wise the cake dog is higher on the list so they are technically overpaying. However the rose dog does have good demand and the cake dogs can have fluctuating demand, so demand wise I would personally value the rose dog more. It depends if you want another cake dog. I personal;y believe the rose will be easier to trade. You may want a second opinion.