The "is this a fair trade?" Thread - info front page!

[Mystra]

Warrior cat confusion! Requesting help.

How or what should I edit to make this fair?
My side is all the cats. Thank you.

Still asking on my original question... Since asking I've had several more trade requests for the same warrior cats...

Trade request #2 for the warriors

Trade request #3

trade request #4 for the warriors

trade request #5 for the warriors

I just want to make a fair trade, get some wishlist pets/items and not rip anyone off but I am utterly useless at figuring out warrior cats value ....

Any help would be much appreciated.

[Relara]

I think #1 is overpay, and again i need help
#2 might be unfair, not sure
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zqnENLA4sA #1
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ambgYei7Lw #2

You'll need to recopy the links - the … broke them for us!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59165046&userid=698931&signature=6HTh_bPOr5iAAgSUmklnwA
is this fair for a balloon dog, ba and bmd?

They're asking for more than the BA and BMD typically go for even considering demand - I would say certainly as far as rarity goes it's unfair to you. Demand… that's a whole different beast lol. All in all I can honestly see some benefits to either side of this trade - personally I think that this point I would keep the holly, halo, and quantity advents because of where I'm at right now - but I was hunting for a blue balloon recently and if I still wanted one I would be so torn on this offer! I don't think you'd be terribly poorly off with their side - but I don't think there's a lot of room for making a profit if that's your aim. The 18th is just around the corner which means trading is gonna go a bit crazy for the next little while - I have no idea what to expect to happen! I'd just think about your goals and what you're aiming for and choose whatever side you think would be better for reaching them. It's a tough call! If you're after a really high demand pet - their side might be better. But if you want to get the most for the pets you have - you might be able to get more as far as value goes. It's so hard to say!

Ty! I edited the trade to this http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 91Z4hDLg-g is it better?

[wonderlandfox]

I know this is unfair to me, but can anyone ballpark what their side might equate to?

Well I've heard nons are worth 3 sorbets. (Or 2..)
With those two nons you would be able to get a Coontail Dog.
So the UR Hollywing and the Pink Balloon + the vixen (?) Would equal a non..
The vixen has nice demand as well as the balloon dog. Due to the UR Hollywing being on UR Flower Pot tier not sure what it goes for, but trade downs I'd think.
The other pets are all nice but wouldn't add up to a second non (in my opinion).
The items are nice. But still wouldn't add up.
If I were you, I'd save the nons with December 18th JUST around the corner ♡

[caster.]

Is this fair? I have no idea what C$ is worth because I've never had any... Thanks in advance.

[wonderlandfox]

Warrior cat confusion! Requesting help.

How or what should I edit to make this fair?
My side is all the cats. Thank you.

Still asking on my original question... Since asking I've had several more trade requests for the same warrior cats...

Trade request #2 for the warriors

Trade request #3

trade request #4 for the warriors

trade request #5 for the warriors

I just want to make a fair trade, get some wishlist pets/items and not rip anyone off but I am utterly useless at figuring out warrior cats value ....

Any help would be much appreciated.

Okay so.
Uncommon warrior cats usually can go up to an '09 rare, or even '08 if lucky.
First trade is way unfair. The recent store pets are only worth a late '10 rare/very rare.
Second trade way unfair once again. Recent store pets are worth '10 rare/very rare and don't have good demand or they have average demand.
Third trade is okay but still wouldn't accept, due to demand and warrior cats being able to go for '09 rares/very rares.
Forth trade is probably the best you've gotten but with that many warrior cats, you could get a tier one advent (in my opinion). I still wouldn't accept. I'd wait for a better offer.
Fifth trade is nice but the '09 rare is really only worth one of the warrior cats.
Wouldn't accept any of them. I'd wait for a better offer.

[Quackers <3]

How does this look for a jeweled liontail? Would like both demand and rarity wise Thank you!

[wonderlandfox]

Is this fair? I have no idea what C$ is worth because I've never had any... Thanks in advance.

Well would be over on their side..
These pets will most likely turn into commons and uncommons.
A common is worth like 0.5 C$.
An uncommon is worth about 1 C$
I'd accept because they are overpaying but depends on if you want C$ ♡

[seraphine.]

Could someone please help tell me if this trade is fair?

Thank you for any help-!

[Pied_piper]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Sj0s8-n8dQ

they said this was unfair even though i felt like I overpayed. Do you think I should add anything?

[wonderlandfox]

Was this fair?
♡