The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Stranger Things]

How good of a trade is THIS? Would it be worth it to do the trade? How good of demand does the bat dog have?

Also THIS?

[BuddyMaltese]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Al5gj5-4Nw

I'm so bad with rares list trades cx How's this?

[Hydra23]

Is this fair?

No !!! Your halo is from 08' and worth a September list, this is extremely unfair to you

[LLHBBB]

Is this fair?

No, the halo alone is worth a Sept list pet. Take that off and it will be closer to being fair as most of the items they added to your side are worth '09 rares and the medieval set tends to go for overpay.

[sushi.jocelyn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58905938&userid=625725&signature=XvRnRxEqp3LWNonNKof7QA
fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NonNKof7QA

[Stranger Things]

How good of a trade is THIS? Would it be worth it to do the trade? How good of demand does the bat dog have?

Also THIS?

[dakotapaws]

fair..?

and this one?

and this one, too?

this one?

[Ginneh]

Is this trade a little more fair for my Elf set?

[Hydra23]

Is this trade a little more fair for my Elf set?

No, now it's unfair to them. I've heard of the elf sets demanding making them go for a 10' rare a piece. I'd say all together they're worth 3 or 4 09' rare

[Frankina]

I've got a bunch of list offers and I need some help distinguishing the
best offers, taking into consideration rarity and demand.
Any advice is highly appreciated!

Offer 1
or
Offer 2
I like both these offers, however I think the BA might be more beneficial for me. The person offering
the BA has also offered BA + purple tox for my sorbet + yellow tox. Any opinions? How is the purple
toxic in terms of demand?

---

Offer 3
I've never had the purple bat dog before, so I'm unsure on how well it trades??
But I'm really wanting to trade up my grinners and bunnies so this offer is tempting.