The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[moonbeam.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NTlhG9wY_g
Rarity wise and Demand wise?

I need some help here ^_^ Thanks for the advance!

[wonderlandfox]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NTlhG9wY_g
Rarity wise and Demand wise?

I need some help here ^_^ Thanks for the advance!

Unfortunately it's unfair to them.
This PPS owl has pretty huge demand compared to any other owl.
The pets you're offering don't add up to the demand and in my opinion the rarity of the owl.
~ Wonderland ~

[fischloughlin]

What could be added to make this fair- demand included, thanks!~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Fi1_5RWX9Q

[future violents]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NTlhG9wY_g
Rarity wise and Demand wise?

I need some help here ^_^ Thanks for the advance!

Unfortunately it's unfair to them.
This PPS owl has pretty huge demand compared to any other owl.
The pets you're offering don't add up to the demand and in my opinion the rarity of the owl.
~ Wonderland ~

It's also worth noting that the owl is from 2009, so it worth at least 2 '09 rares. Your side does not even add up to 1. ^^

[Mero]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ngk2BAu5zQ
Is this fair?? Thank you.

[pigeon -]

Would a spotted tribal = a ur bengal? Demand wise?
I'm not sure where the UR bengal is at the moment in demand so any advice would be a great help!

I think the spotted tribal might be overpay, as I've heard the UR Bengal goes for about a sorbet? List-wise the bengal is only at the Nonballoon tier though, so I'd get a second opinion to make sure!

Edit: After a bit more searching I've found the Bengal might only be demanded at about Red Toxic level, so I'm almost certain you'd be overpaying.

Ah thank you! So can I get a few more opinions? I wanted to see if i could straight swap but more opinions would be great!

[wonderlandfox]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58929878&userid=622799&signature=1H3XVZhNfHvNNgk2BAu5zQ
Is this fair?? Thank you.

Unfair to you.
Even with the demand of the Hollyfox Cat it's on tier five while the patchwork is on tier seven.
The patchwork also has pretty good demand and can somewhat go for overpay due to good demand.
Even with the items they have added I would still say unfair.
• Wonderland •

[dakotapaws]

how fair is this bid?

edit:

and this one?

[Takk]

Edit: After a bit more searching I've found the Bengal might only be demanded at about Red Toxic level, so I'm almost certain you'd be overpaying.

Ah thank you! So can I get a few more opinions? I wanted to see if i could straight swap but more opinions would be great!

[/quote]

Depends on the side of the trade you're on? Someone could certainly get an UR Bengal with a Spotted tribal but not the other way around as the Bengal is worth much, much less than a tribal even including demand

What could be added to make this fair- demand included, thanks!~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Fi1_5RWX9Q

Looks about right demand wise if not slight overpay
The vixen often goes for overpay, but nothing too crazy like a red rose or winged blood dog. Between a hyena and target dog is average in auction

[wonderlandfox]

Would a spotted tribal = a ur bengal? Demand wise?
I'm not sure where the UR bengal is at the moment in demand so any advice would be a great help!

I think the spotted tribal might be overpay, as I've heard the UR Bengal goes for about a sorbet? List-wise the bengal is only at the Nonballoon tier though, so I'd get a second opinion to make sure!

Edit: After a bit more searching I've found the Bengal might only be demanded at about Red Toxic level, so I'm almost certain you'd be overpaying.

Ah thank you! So can I get a few more opinions? I wanted to see if i could straight swap but more opinions would be great!

Even though tribals have lower demand, you'd still be overpaying.
The UR Bengal is around Red Toxic to Sorbet level even though the UR Bengal is on the Non-Balloon tier.
If you were really wanting the UR Bengal and wanted to overpay then you could but I wouldn't.
As stated beforehand you're overpaying ^^
• Wonderland •