The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[DOKONJOFINGER]

Fair?

Also, if I traded a UR Apple for a BMD, what must I add due to the BMD's high demand and the Apples low demand?

[future violents]

Alright I'm looking to end my auction for these horses, which is the most fair/ most over pay. Thanks so much for any and all help!! Will gift whoever can help!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hATtM_Mizg


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a8lzUX0PRQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xVl_xLDWjg

All four of your horses add up to about 2 mid advents, so the most fair offer is the third one. However the first offer is decently fair as well, even considering they added '11 store pet. The only unfair offer is the second, which is unfair to you by 1 mid advent.

[Silverstar]

Alright I'm looking to end my auction for these horses, which is the most fair/ most over pay. Thanks so much for any and all help!! Will gift whoever can help!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hATtM_Mizg


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a8lzUX0PRQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xVl_xLDWjg

The last one is the best, the second one is unfair to you.

[future violents]

Fair?

Also, if I traded a UR Apple for a BMD, what must I add due to the BMD's high demand and the Apples low demand?

They're overpaying by quite a bit. The ferret and the dog are a fine swap.

Even with demand, it wouldn't be necessary to add anything to the UR Apple's side. However, the BMD can go for up to a Balloon Dog, so if they value it that high then the UR Apple would need to add about a Cake Dog tier.

[Frankina]

Factoring in both list and demand, how fair is this trade to my zebra? I'm extremely interested in the bengal but don't want to overpay for it. I know list-wise it's probably not fair as the UR Bengal is at the Nonballoon tier and the Mountain Zebra is at Dogtag level. But I'd like to know overall. Thank you for any help!

Yeah this is extremely unfair for your zebra. The zeb is worth 3 nons and their side
doesn't even total one non, even with the demand of the dragon and Bengal.
Honestly the zebra may have some iffy demand but you can get much more for it
than this, like at least 2 nons worth. I've had it before and found that it was much
easier to trade semi fairly around Dec 18th time when more traders are active.
If you are looking to get the Bengal, I'd advise you to trade down your zebra in steps
until you obtain a lower main list pet, such as a non-balloon to then trade for the Bengal.
The zebra is just too valuable to act as direct payment for a UR Bengal.

[DOKONJOFINGER]

Fair?

Also, if I traded a UR Apple for a BMD, what must I add due to the BMD's high demand and the Apples low demand?

They're overpaying by quite a bit. The ferret and the dog are a fine swap.

Even with demand, it wouldn't be necessary to add anything to the UR Apple's side. However, the BMD can go for up to a Balloon Dog, so if they value it that high then the UR Apple would need to add about a Cake Dog tier.

Okay thank you for both answers!

[Sarcastic Hawke]

Factoring in both list and demand, how fair is this trade to my zebra? I'm extremely interested in the bengal but don't want to overpay for it. I know list-wise it's probably not fair as the UR Bengal is at the Nonballoon tier and the Mountain Zebra is at Dogtag level. But I'd like to know overall. Thank you for any help!

Yeah this is extremely unfair for your zebra. The zeb is worth 3 nons and their side
doesn't even total one non, even with the demand of the dragon and Bengal.
Honestly the zebra may have some iffy demand but you can get much more for it
than this, like at least 2 nons worth. I've had it before and found that it was much
easier to trade semi fairly around Dec 18th time when more traders are active.
If you are looking to get the Bengal, I'd advise you to trade down your zebra in steps
until you obtain a lower main list pet, such as a non-balloon to then trade for the Bengal.
The zebra is just too valuable to act as direct payment for a UR Bengal.

Thank you very much! Could I get a second opinion just to be sure?

[dakotapaws]

how fair is this bid?

edit:

and this one?

[future violents]

Factoring in both list and demand, how fair is this trade to my zebra? I'm extremely interested in the bengal but don't want to overpay for it. I know list-wise it's probably not fair as the UR Bengal is at the Nonballoon tier and the Mountain Zebra is at Dogtag level. But I'd like to know overall. Thank you for any help!

Yeah this is extremely unfair for your zebra. The zeb is worth 3 nons and their side
doesn't even total one non, even with the demand of the dragon and Bengal.
Honestly the zebra may have some iffy demand but you can get much more for it
than this, like at least 2 nons worth. I've had it before and found that it was much
easier to trade semi fairly around Dec 18th time when more traders are active.
If you are looking to get the Bengal, I'd advise you to trade down your zebra in steps
until you obtain a lower main list pet, such as a non-balloon to then trade for the Bengal.
The zebra is just too valuable to act as direct payment for a UR Bengal. :)

Thank you very much! Could I get a second opinion just to be sure?

I completely agree. The Bengal only goes for about a Sorbet and the Zebra can usually get 2 Nons. The Grey Dragon doesn't even come close to covering that gap.

[Sarcastic Hawke]

-snip-

Yeah this is extremely unfair for your zebra. The zeb is worth 3 nons and their side
doesn't even total one non, even with the demand of the dragon and Bengal.
Honestly the zebra may have some iffy demand but you can get much more for it
than this, like at least 2 nons worth. I've had it before and found that it was much
easier to trade semi fairly around Dec 18th time when more traders are active.
If you are looking to get the Bengal, I'd advise you to trade down your zebra in steps
until you obtain a lower main list pet, such as a non-balloon to then trade for the Bengal.
The zebra is just too valuable to act as direct payment for a UR Bengal.

Thank you very much! Could I get a second opinion just to be sure?

I completely agree. The Bengal only goes for about a Sorbet and the Zebra can usually get 2 Nons. The Grey Dragon doesn't even come close to covering that gap.

Thank you guys so much! I really appreciate the prompt replies.