The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[lola843]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58710803&userid=29150&signature=tu3WBI-emgECSQbxu7hJkQ Any help with this? Those VR have me like O.O

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

[Keytone]

is this trade fair assuming that the cats will all end up being either vc or c? quantity always trips me up. xp

I'd say its a bit unfair to you, if the cats is gonna be common and under it ight only be them who is needed the make the trade fair but get a second opinion <3

thank you- second opinion please/what removed or added would make it fair if it isn't? Thank you in advance for any help! c:

[♡Chocolate♡]

Oh, oh, look who is back with another trade. Any help is great, tysm!! <3

Rarity wise is the rare overpay but demand wise is Nick pets not the best, and the lion dosent really make it up the the warriors demand. Tho im not sure.
Get a second opinion! <3

ty, and other opinions?

[Kainé]

What is the demand these days for nons? How are these demand wise and which one is better?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0ha7Pa2cUg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g6t8hvg1fA

[Scarlett.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58722692&userid=678516&signature=A6i90WY--_618MCDSQrZBg

is this fair?!?!?

It's not fair.
Your side is a Tier 4 Advent List White Tinsel Horse; their side probably can't fetch them a Tier 1 Advent.

[kxynine]

So im having an auction, and i wanna know which of those bids is worth more?
Also, have i been giving the right advise? (Whatever you call it)

Bids;
bid 1 Many have said its fair but i dont really like the Nick pet. IF you change it to a higher demand or something like that its great!
bid 2 I can get a high september lost for it and 2 rares and few commons isnt enough sorry ;-;
bid 3 Again, a few storepets and a few rares and some commons-uncommons isnt enough ;-;
bid 4 Its a nice bid! ^^ May be auto but idk imma get some advice <3
bid 5 I love the bid! Tho im most likely looking for lists x3 *Leading bid for now*
bid 6 This isnt fair at all sorry :c Theres only one rare i think and thats just not enough xc

[J.cole]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zoHkRoKZ-g is this demand and rarity wise fair?


please help

[lola843]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58710803&userid=29150&signature=tu3WBI-emgECSQbxu7hJkQ Any help with this? Those VR have me like O.O

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

[/quote]

[Scarlett.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58710803&userid=29150&signature=tu3WBI-emgECSQbxu7hJkQ Any help with this? Those VR have me like O.O

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

For the UR Foal trade, I think you're overpaying rarity wise.
They offered a UR Foal which is below the gap for a Non AND Rose PPS? Nons are worth a UR Flower + Green toxic, and together with the Rose PPS, that's overpay for just a UR Foal. I wouldn't take the trade but it's ultimately up to you if you like the OMGSR rating c:

[Leopardy]

Also this, this causes me great pain because I'm so tempted. Is it techically an overpay with the OMGSR?: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lwSPI4WRRQ

Aand this one has me stumped.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NqeFv8_fGw

Any help is super appreciated! Again, a little something to whoever can help. c:

So, first trade, the UR Foal (what they are offering) isn´t a fair trade to your Pet, the Dogtag.
Yours is above the big gap, theirs is the Purple Toxic Level and I know for a fact that they need to add some Rareslist Pets.
Maybe someone on here can tell you exactly what they need to add, because I´m not exactly sure.

Second Trade is also unfair to you. Your Dogtag is already higher than their UR Phoenix and the added other Pets to your side. Just don´t accept, that´s not fair to you at all.