The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[rare animal]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58617081&userid=28347&signature=4JksMaz9-XekGLCQaadzcA

I don't know much about store pets, is this fair? ^^ Thanks :)

guess I was skipped. Anyone know if this is fair?

in my opinion they should replace the uncommons with the some rares for it to be fair for me but im really bad at trading so
also the store pets honestly dont seem fair..

[pigeon.enthusiast]

Should I accept?

[dakotapaws]

anyone?

Bid One
Bid Two
Bid Three
Bid Four
Bid Five

now which is the best?

edit:
and this one?

Bid 4 and Last bid

I agree^^

thank you. and this one?

[amazonkama]

Is this fair? and I know drafts have bad demand Im just not sure if this would still work for it

Thanks for any help!

Not fair imo, the older pets are mostly commons, then there are only recent pets. You could trade the draft more to a person who likes horses, or someone that just enjoys the pet.

But what about the two items they added on? Would the wig and cape not be enough to cover the gap?
Tho thanks for the other info!

[rare animal]

Should I accept?

Um, maybe?? I dont like rats that much but its double very rare so

[Clayflower]

Should I accept?

Um, maybe?? I dont like rats that much but its double very rare so

Please only give educated advice! Maybe doesn't really help. Anyway, I would say no. You could get higher demand rares for the dragon, which would be more than the rabbit and rat.

[Eagle's Eye]

Is this fair? and I know drafts have bad demand Im just not sure if this would still work for it

Thanks for any help!

Not fair imo, the older pets are mostly commons, then there are only recent pets. You could trade the draft more to a person who likes horses, or someone that just enjoys the pet.

But what about the two items they added on? Would the wig and cape not be enough to cover the gap?
Tho thanks for the other info!

Their side's value is nowhere close to your draft. The items were free from 2013 Halloween(boop) and should only worth roughly a common or uncommon from late 2013, which does not cover the huge gap

[Shadow2204]

anyone?

Bid One
Bid Two
Bid Three
Bid Four
Bid Five

now which is the best?

edit:
and this one?

Bid 4 and Last bid

I agree^^

Your robo cat is worth an early '10 rare and could easily get a '09 rare.
1. Their pps is from June 2009, therefore unfair to the cat.
2. Not sure about the items, but their side is worth two 2009 rares which is a 2009 rare of overpay, in addition, malks can get slight overpay.
3. The store deer is worth a mid '10 rare but it has pretty good demand so could easily get a 2009 rare. The deer along with the other pets is considered as a slight overpay.
4. They are offering a 2008 dog that is worth the 3 month rule or a early 2009 rare which is fair for the cat, if not, slight overpay.
5. The store pet they are offering is worth a late 2010 rare but may be able to get a mid '10 rare. With the rare cat, it would be just about fair though i wouldn't recommend accepting this trade.
(Sorry, can't help with your edit trade)

Personally, i'd take either 2, 3, or 4.

[Bloodpaw/Sangre]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... POZftbehEQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 91DM7hT9Fw

Should I accept any of them?

[pipër]

got this trade for 'em wondering if it's fair ? thanks '